We consider the semiclassical limit of the vacuum Virasoro block describing the diagonal 4-point correlation functions on the sphere. At large central charge c, after exponentiation, it depends on two fixed ratios h H /c and h L /c, where h H,L are the conformal dimensions of the 4-point function operators. The semiclassical block may be expanded in powers of the light ratio h L /c and the leading non-trivial (linear) order is known in closed form as a function of h H /c. Recently, this contribution has been matched against AdS 3 gravity calculations where heavy operators build up a classical geometry corresponding to a BTZ black hole, while the light operators are described by a geodesic in this background. Here, we compute for the first time the next-to-leading quadratic correction O((h L /c) 2 ), again in closed form for generic heavy operator ratio h H /c. The result is a highly nontrivial extension of the leading order and may be relevant for further refined AdS 3 /CFT 2 tests. Applications to the two-interval Rényi entropy are also presented.