Psychiatric Referrals-Bearcroft and Donovan BRITISH 1523 panic-reaction described by Lambo (1962) as the "malignant anxiety state"; two cases required to be nursed in a padded room in prison, both being finally unconvicted of sexual offences; the panic reaction appeared to stem directly from the arrest. The precipitation of schizophreniform episodes in prison is also worthy of comment; five cases illustrated this with sudden hallucinations and delusions, deriving from the stress of imprisonment.Magistrates seem unable to tolerate much psychiatric disturbance in court. The indifference and inattention of the schizophrenic are sometimes regarded as wanton behaviour, and a mild hypomanic outburst is treated as contempt of court.
ConclusionsThe large majority of men referred for psychiatric report and seen by. me in 1963 suffered from schizophrenia (40%) and personality disorders (39%). Neurotic states, especially depression and anxiety, were a common complication of psychopathy. Hypomania was not uncommon, nor were panic reactions in coloured men reacting to stress. Social factors contributed to the incidence of criminal behaviour in the mentally ill; the offence was often a cry for help and was committed when the men felt that they needed treatment or when they, or their relatives for them, were unable to obtain it. Ten per cent. of the homeless who were referred had left good homes on account of their illness and had drifted into a state of social isolation, confirming the views of many psychiatrists regarding the drift of schizophrenic patients. The understanding of the mentally ill by police and the courts still seems poor, and the strict operation of the law in regard to these patients appears to be cumbersome. The period in remand in prison might be better used for a fuller psychiatric and social assessment, and treatment facilities in prison seem urgently needed.The treatment recommended by psychiatrists and prison medical officers is often in the nature of social rehabilitation, which is difficult to arrange from prison, often necessitating hospital admission in the absence of hostel accommodation. The role of the psychiatrist in making recommendations to courts is to suggest disposal of a patient rather than to determine the degree of responsibility for his offence. The number of men coming to the out-patient department after a psychiatric interview in prison but without a specific recommendation for treatment being made to the courts is noteworthy. Many more of those with personality disorders could have been admitted to hospital at the time had treatment facilities been available.
SummaryA study of 146 consecutive men who were referred from courts and prisons for a psychiatric opinion in one year is reported. Medical and social aspects are discussed. The most common diagnostic categories were schizophrenia (40%) and personality disorders (39%)-the latter often associated with neurotic reactions. Frequently more than one diagnosis was made; or an intractable social problem was apparent which seemed to con...