Approximately half of U.S. women giving birth annually receive Pitocin, the synthetic form of oxytocin (OXT), yet its effective dose can vary significantly, presenting safety concerns due to unpredictable responses, which may lead to adverse outcomes for both mother and baby. To address the need for improved dosing, we developed a data-driven mathematical model to predict OXT receptor (OXTR) binding. Our study focuses on five prevalent OXTR variants (V45L, P108A, L206V, V281M, and E339K) and their impact on OXT–OXTR binding dynamics in two distinct cell types: human embryonic kidney cells (HEK293T) and human myometrial smooth muscle cells. We parameterize the model with cell-specific OXTR surface localization measurements. To strengthen the robustness of our study, we conduct a comprehensive meta-analysis of OXT-OXTR binding, enabling parameterization of our model with cell-specific OXT-OXTR binding kinetics (myometrial OXT-OXTR Kd= 1.6 nM, kon= 6.8 × 105M−1min−1, and koff= 0.0011 min−1). Our meta-analysis reveals significant homogeneity in OXT-OXTR affinity across experiments and species with a Kd= 0.52-9.32 nM and mean Kd= 1.48 ± 0.51 nM. Our model achieves valuable several insights into designing dosage strategies. First, we predict that the OXTR complex reaches maximum occupancy at 10 nM OXT in myometrial cells and at 1 µM in HEK293T cells. This information is pivotal for guiding experimental design and data interpretation when working with these distinct cell types, emphasizing the need to consider cell-type-specific effects when choosing OXTR-transfected cell lines. Second, our model recapitulates the significant effects of genetic variants for both experimental and physiologically relevant systems, with V281M and E339K substantially compromising OXT–OXTR binding capacity. These findings suggest the need for personalized oxytocin dosing based on individual genetic profiles to enhance therapeutic efficacy and reduce risks, especially in the context of labor and delivery. Third, we demonstrate the potential for rescuing the attenuated cell response observed in V281M and E339K variants by increasing the OXT dosage at specific, early time points. Cellular responses to OXT, including Ca2+release, manifest within minutes. Our model indicates that providing V281M- and E339K-expressing cells with doubled OXT dose during the initial minute of binding can elevate OXT–OXTR complex formation to levels comparable to wild-type OXTR. In summary, our study provides a computational framework for precision oxytocin dosing strategies, paving the way for personalized medicine.