Abnormal repetitive behaviours in captive birds: a Tinbergian review

Abstract

Abnormal repetitive behaviours (ARBs) are associated with past, or present, welfare problems and are common elements of the behavioural repertoire of some captive animals, including birds. Millions of birds from hundreds of species are held in various captive settings, yet most avian ARB research to-date focuses on just a handful of these. Therefore, our knowledge of ARBs and, by implication, welfare, of a taxonomically diverse range of avian species is poorly understood. The purpose of this review is to begin to address this by providing a useful overview of ARBs across captive avian species. Taking advantage of the research effort on well-studied species, we pool current findings relating to avian ARBs into a coherent framework, highlight gaps in understanding, and use this to give a reference point for future research in both these and other species. We adopt Tinbergen's 'Four Questions' approach to comprehensively consider ARBs from each of his four perspectives. We begin with presenting studies on ARB development, describe how physiological predispositions and early-life housing and experiences impact ARB risk in later life. Next we outline internal causal triggers for ARBs, such as the effects of neurotransmitters, hormones, and dietary deficiencies, and discuss external, environmental triggers for ARBs. In the evolution section, we detail the influence of species' evolutionary history on ARB, and use findings from early molecular studies on laying hens to discuss heritability and genes associated with ARB. The benefits of using cross-species studies to determine underlying evolutionary drivers of ARBs are also illustrated with an example from Psittaciformes. In discussing ARB 'function', we make two tentative suggestions for potential examples of ARB performance allowing a bird to cope, and also consider situations where ARB may be functionless. We then summarise, and discuss, these four interacting perspectives on avian ARBs. To finish, the benefits of Tinbergen's approach are shown in a worked example of an ARB in one species, demonstrating how this valuable framework leads to the most complete understanding of ARB. Thus, by utilising Tinbergen's Four Questions, our review provides a platform for future

Descriptions of the vocalisations of the Chestnut-backed Button-quail Turnix castanotus

“…The lack of research surrounding button-quail is partly because of their cryptic habits, which means that it is extremely difficult to observe natural behaviours in the wild (Debus 1996). Captive populations enable some behaviours to be observed and described (Phipps 1976;Mills 1985;Roulston 1992) but few button-quail species have been held in captivity, and captive environments are known to alter natural behaviours (Mellor et al 2018). Continual advancements in the application and development of remote acoustic recording units as well as autonomous recognition and analysis may provide a detection method for the Chestnut-backed Button-quail and other button-quail species.…”

Conducting Behavioural Research in the Zoo: A Guide to Ten Important Methods, Concepts and Theories

“…Mellor et al [83] expand on how to use a Tinbergian review of abnormal repetitive behaviour in captive birds from a range of species to provide a deeper understanding of why such behaviours occur (using the wild ecology of the animal as the starting point). These authors highlight the importance of the developmental stages of behaviour to influencing the performance of abnormal activities later in life.…”

Romantic Love and Sleep Variations: Potential Proximate Mechanisms and Evolutionary Functions

“…Answering one question provides complementary insights into the other questions [ 3 ]. This approach has been used to describe traits across the major kingdoms of life (e.g., [ 5 , 6 , 7 ]). It has been used to describe complex human traits including infant crying [ 8 ], prosocial bias in favour of attractive people [ 9 ], the female sexual orientation spectrum [ 10 ], and romantic love [ 11 ].…”