Ableism differs by disability, gender and social context: Evidence from vignette experiments

Abstract

Existing research on prejudice and discrimination towards disabled people (i.e. ‘ableism’) has conceptualized it as a general attitude, obscuring the role of social context in its manifestation. We aimed to investigate whether and how ableism manifests differently depending on the nature of the disability, the disabled person's gender and the social context of the interaction. A nationally representative sample of 2000 adults read a series of vignettes about issues faced by disabled people (e.g. employment, relationships). Vignettes varied by presence and type of disability and the disabled person's gender. Judgements about how a disabled person was treated showed clear evidence of ableism towards some conditions (e.g. autism) but not others (e.g. a spine disorder). Judgements about the actions of a disabled person were more nuanced. A disability‐gender intersectionality effect was observed for judgements about romantic relationships, with physically disabled women penalized compared to men but no gender difference was observed for intellectual disability. No intersectionality or ableism was observed on a vignette about refusing poorly paid work. We find clear evidence that ableism manifests differently depending on the nature of the individual's disability, their gender and the social context, questioning previous conceptualizations of ableism as a general attitude.

Attitudes towards immigration and refugees in Ireland: Understanding recent trends and drivers

“…Similar to the policy questions presented in the previous section, this vignette experiment was fielded as part of a larger study of attitudes to disability in Ireland in August 2022 (Timmons et al, 2023a). While the overall survey contained 2,000 participants, the vignettes experiment was designed so that each version of the vignette would be shown to at least 250 participants (see Timmons et al, 2023b).…”

“…While the acceptability of objection against Ukrainian refugees was slightly higher than for asylum seekers (see Figure 5.4), this difference in judgement was not statistically significant (χ² = 0.64, p = .422). NDA Vignette experiments of attitudes to disability (Timmons et al, 2023b).…”

The equality impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on the Irish labour market

“…Sixty per cent of these respondents reported worsening financial situations and over 70 per cent reported that COVID-19 affected their ability to pay 11 Defined as prejudice, discrimination, and the application of stigma toward people with disabilities (Friedman and Owen, 2017; see also Timmons et al, 2023).…”