It is usually assumed that when Weyl invariance is unbroken in the electromagnetic sector, the energy density of primordial magnetic fields will redshift as radiation. Here we show that primordial magnetic fields do not exhibit radiation-like redshifting in the presence of stronger electric fields, as a consequence of Faraday's law of induction. In particular for the standard Maxwell theory, magnetic fields on super-horizon scales can redshift as B 2 ∝ a −6 H −2 , instead of the usually assumed a −4 . Taking into account this effect for inflationary magnetogenesis can correct previous estimates of the magnetic field strength by up to 37 orders of magnitude. This opens new possibilities for inflationary magnetogenesis, and as an example we propose a scenario where femto-Gauss intergalactic magnetic fields are created on Mpc scales, with high-scale inflation producing observable primordial gravitational waves, and reheating happening at low temperatures.1 Most of the analyses in [6] are based on directly solving the gauge field's equation of motion, arriving at the correct scaling behavior of the magnetic field. However their Section 3.2 assumes the redshifting (1.1) and thus can be modified by taking into account the proper magnetic scaling.2 Non-radiation-like redshifting of magnetic fields has also been claimed for anisotropic [18] or open [19] universes, although the mechanism for the open universe was strongly questioned in [20]. Other proposals exist as well, e.g. [21]. However we stress that the effect discussed in the current paper is different from those. 3 One can also consider other options, like the generation of helical magnetic fields from a coupling of the type I 2 FµνF µν , whereF is the dual field strength [22]. Such mechanisms however suffer from their own backreaction, anisotropy and perturbativity constraints [23,24] yielding similar problems for magnetogenesis [25].