A Viability Quantitative PCR Dilemma: Are Longer Amplicons Better?

Abstract

The development of viability qPCR (v-qPCR) has allowed for a more accurate assessment of the viability of a microbial sample by limiting the amplification of DNA from dead cells. Although valuable, v-qPCR is not infallible. One of the most limiting factors for accurate live/dead distinction is the length of the qPCR amplicon used. However, no consensus or guidelines exist for selecting and designing amplicon lengths for optimal results. In this study, a wide range of incrementally increasing amplicon lengths (68-906 bp) was used on live and killed cells of nine bacterial species treated with viability dye (PMA). Increasing amplicon lengths up to approximately 200 bp resulted in increasing quantification cycle (Cq) differences between live and killed cells, while maintaining a good qPCR efficiency. Longer amplicon lengths, up to approximately 400 bp, further increased Cq difference, but at the cost of qPCR efficiency. Above 400 bp, no valuable increase in Cq differences was observed. Importance Viability qPCR (v-qPCR) has evolved to a valuable, mainstream technique for determining the number of viable micro-organisms in samples by qPCR. Amplicon length is known to be positively correlated with the ability to distinguish between live and dead bacteria but is negatively correlated with qPCR efficiency. This trade-off is often not taken into account and might have an impact on the accuracy of v-qPCR data. Currently there is no consensus on the optimal amplicon length. This paper provides methods to determine the optimal amplicon length and suggests an amplicon length range for optimal v-qPCR, taking into consideration the trade-off between qPCR efficiency and live-dead distinction.

Differences in chlorhexidine mouthrinses formulations influence the quantitative and qualitative changes in in‐vitro oral biofilms

“…DNA from the pelleted bacterial cells was then extracted using QIAamp DNA Mini‐kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany) following the manufacturer's instructions. The qPCR assay was performed using a CFX96 Real‐Time System (Bio‐Rad, Hercules, CA, USA) and its associated software CFX Manager (version 3.1), using strain‐specific primers and probes according to Van Holm and co‐workers 20 …”

Strategy to Evaluate Changes in Bacterial Community Profiles and Bacterial Pathogen Load Reduction After Sewage Disinfection

“…To enable a fast amplification process and reduce the chance of polymerization error, short amplicons (<200 bp) are preferred. However, shorter amplicons increase the chance of false-positive detection of non-viable cell DNA due to the insufficient binding of PMA molecules to short DNA fragments (Van Holm et al, 2021 ). In this study, salmon testes DNA (77bp) as the control to quantify the PMA treatment efficiencies had an amplicon length shorter than those of the bacterial gene targets ( Table 1 ).…”

Point-of-Care Lateral Flow Detection of Viable Escherichia coli O157:H7 Using an Improved Propidium Monoazide-Recombinase Polymerase Amplification Method

“…PMAxx was reported to be more effective at excluding amplification from dead cells when longer amplicons were used compared with when used with smaller amplicons [ 56 ]. Amplicons below 200 bp are not recommended with qPCR [ 57 ]. The rfbE F1/R1 primer set also showed reproducibility and consistency with variable parameters between viable and non-viable cells, showing the robustness of the PMAxx-RPA-LFA assay [ 30 ].…”