A Unique Lens: Understanding What Nurses Are Best Positioned to Assess About Residents

Abstract

Background Resident feedback is generally elicited from attending physicians, although nurses can also provide feedback on distinct domains. Physicians may be hesitant to accept feedback from nurses if they perceive that nurses are being asked about areas outside their expertise. Understanding specific resident behaviors that nurses are best suited to assess is critical to successful implementation of feedback from nurses to residents. Objective To understand specific resident behaviors nurses are uniquely positioned to assess from the perspectives of both nurses and residents. Methods We performed a qualitative study using thematic analysis of 5 focus groups with 20 residents and 5 focus groups with 17 nurses at a large free-standing children's hospital in 2020. Two reviewers developed a codebook and subsequently analyzed all transcripts. Codes were organized into themes and subthemes. Thematic saturation was achieved prior to analyzing the final transcript. Results We identified 4 major themes. Nurses are positioned to provide feedback: (1) on residents' interprofessional collaborative practice; (2) on residents' communication with patients and their families; and (3) on behalf of patients and their families. Within each of these, we identified subthemes noting specific behaviors on which nurses can provide feedback. The fourth theme encompassed topics that may not be best suited for nursing feedback—medical decision-making and resident responsiveness. Conclusions Nurses and residents described specific resident behaviors that nurses were best positioned to assess.