“…Heimann et al (11) reported that we found only small amounts of silicon, aluminum, and iron, implying that this was the case for all samples studied. However, such low concentrations apply only to the nontronite-graphite intergrowth, where the nontronite is a minor component; for the other three samples that we described, the EDS signals were very strong and could not have arisen from minor surface contaminants.…”