Endoscopic injection of India ink using standard sclerotherapy needles can inadvertently tattoo extraintestinal sites in addition to tattooing the primary lesion. Despite its striking appearance, this intraoperative, gross, and microscopic finding is likely not pathologically significant, given its proposed pathophysiology. Surgical recognition of this entity is important, however, to prevent misinterpretation of findings as peritoneal melanoma, endometrial implants, infarcted mesentery, or tattooed cancer. This complication may be prevented by proper tattooing technique.