A Thematic Analysis of Stigma and Disclosure for Perinatal Depression on an Online Forum

Abstract

BackgroundPerinatal mental illness is a global health concern; however, many women do not get the treatment they need to recover. Some women choose not to seek professional help and get no treatment because they feel stigmatized. Online forums for various health conditions, including perinatal mental health, can be beneficial for members. Little is known about the role that online forums for perinatal mental illness play in reducing stigma and subsequent disclosure of symptoms to health care providers and treatment uptake.ObjectiveThis study aimed to examine stigma and disclosure in forums and describe any potential disadvantages of forum use.MethodsAn online forum for mothers was examined and 1546 messages extracted from 102 threads from the antenatal and postnatal depression section. These messages were subjected to deductive systematic thematic analysis to identify common themes regarding stigma and disclosure of symptoms and potential disadvantages of forum use.ResultsTwo major themes were identified: stigma and negative experiences of disclosure. Stigma had 3 subthemes: internal stigma, external stigma, and treatment stigma. Many women were concerned about feeling like a “bad” or “failed” mother and worried that if they disclosed their symptoms to a health care provider they would be stigmatized. Posts in response to this frequently encouraged women to disclose their symptoms to health care providers and accept professional treatment. Forum discourse reconstructed the ideology of motherhood as compatible with perinatal mental illness, especially if the woman sought help and adhered to treatment. Many women overcame stigma and replied that they had taken advice and disclosed to a health care provider and/or taken treatment.ConclusionsForum use may increase women's disclosure to health care providers by challenging their internal and external stigma and this may strengthen professional treatment uptake and adherence. However, a few posts described negative experiences when disclosing to health care providers.

What are women stressed about after birth?

“…Some issues identified in previous literature were not found in the current study, for example, pressure to regain prebaby figure . Cross‐cutting themes were also consistent with previous literature suggesting negative self‐appraisals (eg, being a bad mum) are common . Support is also known to be important in the postpartum period with potential direct and indirect effects on women's psychological well‐being …”

Breastfeeding experiences and support for women who are overweight or obese: A mixed‐methods systematic review

“…It is possible that women who could benefit from tailored support for breastfeeding are reluctant to seek help because of concerns about the stigma of their weight: a similar situation to perinatal mental health where women have described being reluctant to report mental health problems because of being perceived as “bad mothers” (Moore, Ayers, & Drey, ). Attention needs to be given to the education of maternity care professionals, including strategies on how to avoid stigmatising women, development of effective communication skills, and evidence of why breastfeeding is so important for maternal and infant health.…”

Isolated, overwhelmed, and worried: Young first‐time mothers asking for information and support online

“…These emotions can arise from physical tiredness, anxiety over their performance as a parent, lack of knowledge over what to expect as a mother, lack of appropriate support and lack of knowledge about what is 'normal' in terms of child development, behaviour and health. A common finding is that mothers are reluctant to discuss the negative aspects of motherhood including depression, for fear of being judged, especially by health professionals (Loudon, Buchanan, & Ruthven, 2016;Moore, Ayers, & Drey, 2016).…”