A matrix of 117 morphological characters scored for 77 terminal taxa was subjected to parsimony analysis under equal and implied weighting schemes and to Bayesian inference in order to test the relationships in and between Stephanopis and Sidymella species, as well as its implications for the systematics of the subfamily Stephanopinae. A sensitivity test was performed to evaluate nodal stability. Our results indicate the polyphyletism of both genera and the topologies obtained allowed the proposition of the following taxonomic acts: The "altifrons clade" is the only group considered as Stephanopis (stricto sensu), with species restricted to the Australian region; most species from the Neotropical region, hitherto attributed to this genus, formed the well-supported "pentacantha clade", while two of them, restricted to Central America, were recovered as the "championi clade". The latter shows significative evidences for the revalidation of Paratobias gen. rev.; the "cambridgei clade" emerged with I. punctata nested within, having all its component species transferred to Isala. None of the Sidymella species with Australian distribution seems to be part of this genus, which occurs in fact only in the Neotropical region and is closely related to Coenypha. This latter has an increment of three species transferred from Stephanopis. Aside from the "lucida clade", which is considered here as Sidymella (stricto sensu), three other groups and a single species emerged apart from this genus: the "hirsuta clade", "trapezia clade", "angularis clade" and Si. rubrosignata. Morphological evidences seem to justify the proposition of all these groups as new genera.