A Tale of Two Countries---the United States and Japan: Are Differences in Health Due to Differences in Overweight?

Abstract

BackgroundDespite similar standards of living and health care systems for older persons, there are marked differences in the relative health of the elderly populations in the United States (US) and Japan. We explore the association of overweight and obesity with these health disparities.MethodsData on older adults from the US National Health Interview Survey (1994) and the Longitudinal Study of Aging II (1994) were compared to similar data from the 1999-2001 Nihon University Japanese Longitudinal Study of Aging. Regression analyses for the 2 countries were conducted to examine the correlates of being overweight and obese, and the relationships of overweight and obesity with activities of daily living functioning, heart disease, arthritis, and diabetes.ResultsThe prevalence of overweight and obesity is higher in the US than in Japan, as is the prevalence of heart disease, diabetes, arthritis, and functioning problems. Education level and marital status are predictors of overweight for older Americans but not for older Japanese people. Health behaviors affect weight in all groups. The prevalence of functioning problems and disease are more likely to be associated with being overweight in US men and women than in Japanese women, and are not associated with being overweight in Japanese men.ConclusionDespite similar standards of living and health care systems for older persons, the conditions associated with poor health differ in the US and Japan. Being overweight or obese appears to be related to more functioning problems and arthritis in the US than in Japan.

Attenuated Age‐Related Increases in Arterial Stiffness in Japanese and American Women

“…In the present study, which was limited to an apparently healthy population, body weight and body fat were significantly greater in U.S. than Japanese adults, although higher body weight or BMI is not always associated with greater mortality in either country, and most countries are experiencing increases in the prevalence of obesity . One of the few studies to address cross‐national differences between Japan and the United States noted that the prevalence of heart disease and diabetes mellitus was higher in the United States than in Japan but that the differences were rather small. Consistent with this, the current study found that the differences in BMI between the two samples were small and that adjusting for BMI did not affect the overall findings on intercountry differences in arterial stiffness.…”

Increasing body weight and risk of limitations in activities of daily living: a systematic review and meta‐analysis

“…Briefly, within these study populations, the sample sizes ranged from 763 (19) to 69,492 (20), baseline measurements were collected prior to the year 2000 in all but one cross‐sectional study population (20), and all study populations except for one longitudinal (10) reported mean age or age ranges over 65 years old, or did not report mean age at all. All study populations were Caucasian, with the exception of a Japanese (21) and Puerto Rican Hispanic (9) population. BMI was self‐reported in 10 study populations and measured in 7.…”

A Comparison of Biological Risk Factors in Two Populations: The United States and Japan

“…While we recognize that the clinical significance of particular thresholds may differ across countries (e.g., with respect to weight: Ito et al 2003; Reynolds et al 2008; WHO Expert Consultation 2004), we use the same cutpoints for all markers in the two countries. We also examine treatment for hypertension and elevated cholesterol.…”