A Systematic Review of Time Series Classification Techniques Used in Biomedical Applications

Abstract

Background: Digital clinical measures collected via various digital sensing technologies such as smartphones, smartwatches, wearables, and ingestible and implantable sensors are increasingly used by individuals and clinicians to capture the health outcomes or behavioral and physiological characteristics of individuals. Time series classification (TSC) is very commonly used for modeling digital clinical measures. While deep learning models for TSC are very common and powerful, there exist some fundamental challenges. This review presents the non-deep learning models that are commonly used for time series classification in biomedical applications that can achieve high performance. Objective: We performed a systematic review to characterize the techniques that are used in time series classification of digital clinical measures throughout all the stages of data processing and model building. Methods: We conducted a literature search on PubMed, as well as the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE), Web of Science, and SCOPUS databases using a range of search terms to retrieve peer-reviewed articles that report on the academic research about digital clinical measures from a five-year period between June 2016 and June 2021. We identified and categorized the research studies based on the types of classification algorithms and sensor input types. Results: We found 452 papers in total from four different databases: PubMed, IEEE, Web of Science Database, and SCOPUS. After removing duplicates and irrelevant papers, 135 articles remained for detailed review and data extraction. Among these, engineered features using time series methods that were subsequently fed into widely used machine learning classifiers were the most commonly used technique, and also most frequently achieved the best performance metrics (77 out of 135 articles). Statistical modeling (24 out of 135 articles) algorithms were the second most common and also the second-best classification technique. Conclusions: In this review paper, summaries of the time series classification models and interpretation methods for biomedical applications are summarized and categorized. While high time series classification performance has been achieved in digital clinical, physiological, or biomedical measures, no standard benchmark datasets, modeling methods, or reporting methodology exist. There is no single widely used method for time series model development or feature interpretation, however many different methods have proven successful.

COVID-19 Patterns in Araraquara, Brazil: A Multimodal Analysis

“…The changes in epidemiological patterns shown in our analysis varied as the pandemic progressed, which is expected in time-series assessments [ 66 ]. Thus, the evolution of control measures and the management of cases had to be correlated with the variability of the patterns exhibited in one urban setting.…”

Recurrence Rate spectrograms for the classification of nonlinear and noisy signals

“…. 5 Extracted from the RP are a range of RQA measures. The Recurrence Rate (RR) represents the amount of recurrence points in a RP relative to its size, i.e.…”

“…The system is explicitly described by three differential equations 5 As a property of the discrete Fourier transform [26], the equality in equation ( 6) is attained from the auto-correlation function using the cyclic continuation of the underlying signal x. However, the potential numerical error is assumed to be negligible.…”

“…Dynamical systems are often mathematically described by nonlinear differential equations, which are difficult to solve using analytical calculus, and commonly require simplification and approximation. Real-world problems related to engineering [1], biology [2], chemistry [3], physics [4], medicine [5] (neuroscience) or economy [6], regularly deal with nonlinear observations to which the underlying formulae are unknown, revealing the significance of nonlinear time series analysis [7,8]. Often important signal figures are neglected or are assumed as noise, especially when only analyzing the Fourier transform {i} spectrum.…”

Biomedical Signal Processing: Understanding Its Importance and Several Fundamental Steps

“…The overall impact of ECG composition has been highlighted in the preliminary identification of cardiac dysfunctions to prevent severe uncertain events in the heart. Other devices such as glucose monitor, EHR, EEG that have been used in the clinical diagnosis also accelerate the enactment of biomedical signal processing in medicine along with the pharmaceutical field [18]. Advanced technological implication in machine learning considering biomedical signal processing in medical aspects increases the probability of curable treatment that is a significant symbol of medical progression.…”