A Systematic Review: Effectiveness of Interventions to De-escalate Workplace Violence against Nurses in Healthcare Settings

Abstract

Workplace violence (WPV) is an increasing cause of concern around the globe, and healthcare organizations are no exception. Nurses may be subject to all kinds of workplace violence due to their frontline position in healthcare settings. The purpose of this systematic review is to identify and consider different interventions that aim to decrease the magnitude/prevalence of workplace violence against nurses. The standard method by Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA, 2009) has been used to collect data and assess methodological quality. Altogether, twenty-six studies are included in the review. The intervention procedures they report on can be grouped into three categories: stand-alone trainings designed to educate nurses; more structured education programs, which are broader in scope and often include opportunities to practice skills learned during the program; multicomponent interventions, which often include organizational changes, such as the introduction of workplace violence reporting systems, in addition to workplace violence training for nurses. By comparing the findings, a clear picture emerges; while standalone training and structured education programs can have a positive impact, the impact is unfortunately limited. In order to effectively combat workplace violence against nurses, healthcare organizations must implement multicomponent interventions, ideally involving all stakeholders.

Prevalence and health correlates of workplace violence and discrimination against hospital employees – a cross-sectional study in German-speaking Switzerland

“…Managing violence and discrimination at workplace is an important issue that has been addressed by different intervention studies in the health care setting [ 54 – 58 ]. More or less effective interventions were identified such as training sessions and education programs (for example in communication skills) or organizational policies and practicies (such as introducing reporting systems or safety procedures, formulating no-tolerance policies, promoting people-oriented culture through open communication, cooperation, trust and participation in decision-making).…”

Perceptions of patient aggression in psychiatric hospitals: a qualitative study using focus groups with nurses, patients, and informal caregivers

“…As the evidence focused on organizational interventions for preventing and minimizing aggression is still of low-quality, more studies in this area are needed [ 53 ]. A recent review proposed that to prevent patient aggression in healthcare organizations, the approaches should include multicomponent interventions, ideally involving all stakeholders [ 54 ] Our study showed that it is feasible to involve different stakeholders in joint initiatives to reach a shared understanding of the current situation and identify common problems, which might help to make new approaches more acceptable to different parties.…”

An exploratory study on the prevalence of workplace violence: the case of Algerian hospitals

“…Recently, this occupational risk has significantly increased in terms of frequency and severity (Singh, 2017; Alsharari et al , 2021; Brunero et al , 2021; Somani et al , 2021) and has been exacerbated by the health crisis caused by the Corona Virus pandemic, in which healthcare workers are confronted with a large number of patients (Ramacciati and Giusti, 2020; Bhattacharjee, 2021).…”