A Statistical Equilibrium Approach to the Distribution of Profit Rates

Abstract

Motivated by classical political economy we detail a probabilistic, statistical equilibrium approach to explaining why even in equilibrium, the equalization of profit rates leads to a non-degenerate distribution. Based on this approach we investigate the empirical content of the profit rate distribution for previously unexamined annual firm level data comprising over 24,000 publicly listed North American firms for the period 1962-2014. We find strong evidence for a structural organization and equalization of profit rates on a relatively short time scale both at the economy wide and one-and two-digit SIC industry levels into a Laplace or double exponential distribution. We show that the statistical equilibrium approach is consistent with economic theorizing about profit rates and discuss research questions emerging from this novel look at profit rate distributions. We also highlight the applicability of the underlying principle of maximum entropy for inference in a wide range of economic topics. . We are grateful to two anonymous referees for their helpful feedback on an earlier version.

Quantal Response Statistical Equilibrium in Economic Interactions: Theory and Estimation

“…), we calculate the rate of profit as the ratio of the difference between total revenue and operating costs to total assets which have been shown to approximate a statistical equilibrium distribution [11][12][13]. The marginal frequency distribution of profit rates deviations for a sample year 1975 is plotted in Figure 2.…”

Quantitative Empirical Research in Marxist Political Economy: A Selective Review

“…They find that for small T , the distributions are asymmetric and much more leptokurtic to the left of the mode (figure 6, Alfarano et al ., ). In a similar contribution, Scharfenaker and Semieniuk () use data for U.S. firms from the Compustat/CRSP Annual Northern American Fundamentals database for the period between 1962 and 2014, to show that firm‐level profit rate distributions are approximated well with a Laplace distribution before 1980 and with an asymmetric Laplace distribution in the period since then. What could explain the increasing asymmetry of the Laplace distribution since 1980?…”

“…To derive the empirically observed probability distributions of the rate of profit, Scharfenaker and Semieniuk () and Alfarano et al . () adopt different strategies.…”

The Principle of Social Scaling

“…This includes a number of quantities that are central to the functioning of financial markets and broader capitalist economies: changes in financial asset prices, their correlations over different time horizons, and financial-market trading volumes [4][5][6][7][8][9]; individual income and wealth [10][11][12][13][14]; corporate rates of growth and profitability [15][16][17][18][19]; the measure of corporate security prices given by Tobin's [20,21]; and daily changes in foreign exchange rates [22]. These findings are an interesting development for economic analysis, which confronts complex social systems shaped by evolving patterns of interaction between large numbers of individuals whose own characteristics and behavior are socially conditioned.…”