A socio-relational framework of sex differences in the expression of emotion

Abstract

Despite a staggering body of research demonstrating sex differences in expressed emotion, very few theoretical models (evolutionary or non-evolutionary) offer a critical examination of the adaptive nature of such differences. From the perspective of a socio-relational framework, emotive behaviors evolved to promote the attraction and aversion of different types of relationships by advertising the two most parsimonious properties of reciprocity potential, or perceived attractiveness as a prospective social partner. These are the individual's (a) perceived capacity or ability to provide expedient resources, or to inflict immediate harm onto others, and their (b) perceived trustworthiness or probability of actually reciprocating altruism (Vigil 2007). Depending on the unique social demands and relational constraints that each sex evolved, individuals should be sensitive to advertise "capacity" and "trustworthiness" cues through selective displays of dominant versus submissive and masculine versus feminine emotive behaviors, respectively. In this article, I introduce the basic theoretical assumptions and hypotheses of the framework, and show how the models provide a solid scaffold with which to begin to interpret common sex differences in the emotional development literature. I conclude by describing how the framework can be used to predict condition-based and situation-based variation in affect and other forms of expressive behaviors.

Want to make me emotional? The influence of emotional advertisements on women’s consumption behavior

“…Since it is claimed that women are the most powerful consumers (Tomlinson, 2007), we take this as a basis to measure Chinese women's response towards ACE-based advertisements. Since some studies suggest that women express emotions three times, on average, more than the men do (Vigil, 2009), the results presented in this study may provide some guidelines to Chinese marketing and advertising professionals to effectively boost business volumes in China by influencing Chinese women's consumption and contagion behavior. ACE research dimensions encapsulated in this study may provoke constructive discussions on advertising and marketing in the Chinese context.…”

“…Vigil (2009) notes that women may have a strong response in understanding the emotions of others, and may express their emotions more than men do. Further, women's emotionally expressive behavior may influence the consumption behavior of other people around them, for example, friends, family members, and children (Khan and Nasr, 2011).…”

“…Further, it has been documented that men and women may have different emotional responses towards advertised products, which may impact their attention and consumption patterns. This may further impact the success or failure of the advertised product (Donges et al, 2012;Vigil, 2009;Lwin and Phau, 2013). Hence, the identification of the proper audience for the advertisement is important to consider for advertisers when developing their advertisements.…”

Air Ions and Mood Outcomes: a Review and Metaanalysis

“…Furthermore, no study reported responses to air ion therapy by gender. Specific tests for differential responses, however, would have been of interest given that gender specific-differences are reported in the literature for many emotional parameters [55][56][57].…”

Gendering the Machine: Preferred Virtual Assistant Gender and Realism in Self-Service

“…Similarity-attraction theory predicts preferences for gender-matching. This may be especially the case for females [ 6], [ 32] who have been found to prefer interacting with other females [ 37], not necessarily because they like females more than males, but because males, as a dominant group, pose more threat [ 38]. As a result of women's greater inter-dependence (relative to male independence), they tend to use similarity as the basis for social bonds [ 34].…”