A rural shelter in Ontario adapting to address the changing needs of women who have experienced intimate partner violence: a qualitative case study

Abstract

A B S T R A C TIntroduction: Intimate partner violence is a significant public health problem, with shelters offering the predominant communitybased solution. Shelters in Canada are mandated to provide a safe place, protection planning, advocacy and counseling among other services. Recently it has been noted the role of the shelter was shifting from an inpatient to outpatient model with a focus on increased integration of health and social services. This changing role of the shelter is amplified within the rural context where resources and cultural norms may be limited or incompatible with help-seeking behaviors. Women's shelters located in rural settings provide services within a specific cultural context that can be at odds with the needs of women who have experienced abuse, because cultural values such as rural pride, lack of anonymity, and lack of services may inhibit access to health and social services. Methods: The purpose of this in-depth qualitative case study was to examine and explore how one rural Canadian women's shelter role was changing and how the shelter was adapting to achieve the changing role. The theoretical framework utilized was a feminist intersectional lens. Qualitative interviews (averaging 60 minutes) were conducted with shelter service providers (n=6) and women staying in the shelter or utilizing shelter services (n=4). Throughout semi-structured interviews, data-trustworthy steps were taken including member-checking and paraphrasing to ensure data were an accurate representation of participants' experiences. Inductive content analysis of all interviews and field notes was conducted independently by two researchers. Results: Analysis revealed the shelter's role was changing to include filling gaps, case management, and system navigation. To achieve the changing role, relationship building, community mobilization (both education and empowerment), and redesigning © T Mantler, B Wolfe, 2016. A Licence to publish this material has been given to James Cook University, http://www.jcu.edu.au 2 delivery were implemented as adaptation strategies. Together both the changing role of the shelter and the adaptation strategies being implemented were found to be working toward a larger goal of transformation of cultural and structural norms related to violence against women. Conclusions: This study uniquely identified the specific changes to the role of one rural Canadian shelter and the adaptations strategies utilized to adapt to the changing needs of women. The changing role of the shelter and the adaptation strategies being utilized have significant implications for the health of women given the increased use of healthcare services for women who have experienced violence. Specifically, the changing role of the shelter has the potential to decrease healthcare service use while increasing the potential fit of services. Further research is required to assess the impact of the changing role of the shelter on the healthcare needs and outcomes for women who have experienced intimate partner violence.Ke...

Examining the Impact of Trauma-Informed Cognitive Behavioral Therapy on Perinatal Mental Health Outcomes Among Survivors of Intimate Partner Violence (The PATH Study): Protocol for a Feasibility Study

“…Upon enrollment in the study, a safety plan will be enacted, outlining secure methods of communication (via email and telephone), information storage, and an emergency protocol if contact with the participant is lost unexpectedly. This particular safety plan has been utilized successfully by both principal investigators in previous research involving survivors of IPV without any adverse events [ 32 ]. To further mitigate the risk that perpetrators of violence will discover their partner’s involvement in the study, strict privacy and confidentiality precautions will be adhered to during the transfer and storage of participants’ health information and demographic data.…”

Percepção das mulheres em situação de violência sobre o apoio formal: Scoping review

“…After analyzing the studies, some characteristics became evident, such as: mean age of 41 years old, and race varying between black, brown, white and indigenous. As for race and ethnicity, 43.7% [13][14][15]17,20,21,23,24 did not highlighted them and 56.2% 14,16,18,19,22,[25][26][27][28] classified race or ethnicity, but did not relate this to violence. That is what was found in a 2019 study, in which age, race or skin color, did not show a relationship of greater possibility for women to suffer violence, but the relationship among the women with less schooling and with fewer children.…”

“…14, [16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25]27,28 Actions classified as potential generated self-confidence and reflection on the context experienced and, in some cases, generated the exit from coexistence with the aggressor.…”

“…One of the studies 20 highlighted the importance of relationship building, effective connection of the services, community mobilization with health education and awareness of intersectoral work. Others 13,15 that superficial or reductionist services can generate non-demand by these women, mainly in the difficulty in accessing the services.…”

Mulheres abrigadas na Casa Lilás

“…A análise dos achados, revela que o serviço prestado pelo abrigo está implementando estratégias para abranger a educação, no enfrentamento da violência contra a mulher. 16 Outra face do estudo sinaliza que a maioria das mulheres estava desempregada (54,8%) ou exercia atividade doméstica não remunerada (11%). Estudo semelhante, em casa abrigo para mulheres em situação de violência, identificou que 27,1% das mulheres acolhidas estavam desempregadas ou exerciam atividade não remunerada e a maioria (29,3%) das mulheres trabalhava na indústria.…”