A Review of the Radiocarbon Dates for the Afanasyevo Culture (Central Asia): Shifting Towards the “Shorter” Chronology

Abstract

This article provides a summary and in-depth analysis of all existing radiocarbon (14C) dates for the Afanasyevo Culture of the Paleometal period. The previous “long” chronology of the culture was widely criticized and contradicted many archaeological observations. The exceedingly wide ranges of the liquid scintillation counting (LSC) dates from bone samples produced in several laboratories and the systematically older ages for the wood/charcoal samples finally reveal the shortcomings of the conventional “long” chronology. From accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS), the Afanasyevo burials of the Altai are dated to the 31st–29th century BC, whereas those of the Middle Yenisei Region to the 29th–25th century BC, which confirms the relatively earlier age of the Altai monuments. The “short” chronology removes the incompatibility of deriving the Afanasyevo Culture from the Yamnaya Culture, which previously appeared “younger” than the Afanasyevo, and also contradictions with the archaeological data. It also explains the small number of sites, the small size of the cemeteries and the lack of the internal periodization. We can now clearly move, from the earlier understanding that the Afanasyevo chronology is too broad, towards a different perception. The new AMS dates only represent a “core” for the Afanasyevo chronology, which cannot be narrowed down, but could be slightly expanded over time.

Burial ground of the Karasuk III afanasyevo culture: results of new investigations

“…до н. э. (Poliakov et al 2019). Однако это лишь только первый шаг в решении целого комплекса проблем.…”

Radiocarbon dates from the Andronov (Fyodorovo) culture sites on the Middle Yenisei

“…Как было прослежено для афанасьевской культуры этого же региона, даты, полученные по образцам дерева жидкостно-сцинтилляционным методом, оказываются необоснованно удревнены (Поляков и др. 2017;Poliakov et al 2019). Нельзя исключать, что подобные проблемы могли сказаться и на датировке андроновских памятников.…”

The Past of Humankind as seen by the Petersburg Archaeologists at the Dawn of the Millenium (to the Centennial of the Russian Academic Archaeology)

“…(Поляков, Святко, 2009; Поляков, 2010). Однако в настоящее время стало очевидным, что бытование афанасьевской культуры на протяжении 1400-1500 лет не соответствует археологическим реалиям (Степанова, 2009; Вадецкая и др., 2014 др., 2017б;Poliakov et al, 2019). Это позволяет предполагать, что и на Среднем Енисее очень ранние даты могильника Малиновый Лог (37-34 вв.…”