A review of South African primary school literacy interventions from 2005 to 2020

Abstract

Background: Learner performance in literacy in the primary education sector is in a state of crisis in South Africa. Whilst many more learners have physical access to education post-1994, the quality of education remains polarised along socio-economic lines. This article sets out to engage with current literature on literacy interventions implemented in South Africa in order to develop an understanding of the key features of interventions, which affect positive change.Aim: This review provides an overview of the scope and type of primary school-level literacy interventions embarked upon in the last 15 years in South Africa. An analysis of some of the key findings on the impact of these interventions is provided.Method: A systematic review was conducted using the key words ‘literacy intervention’ and ‘reading intervention’. The selection of articles was further refined with a specific focus on primary school interventions in South Africa.Results: The review focuses on specific literacy interventions where ‘intervention’ is defined as active and purposeful engagement to improve decoding, vocabulary, fluency and/or comprehension of primary school learners. This article reviews the documented literacy interventions and draws out some of the key features of successful interventions. It also makes broader reflective comments about what this exercise reveals about the state of literacy interventions in South Africa.Conclusion: Interventions have generally been ad hoc and uncoordinated and have not wrought systemic change. Moving forward in a coordinated manner must be based amongst other things on learning from interventions that have been reviewed here.

Pengembangan Aplikasi Android dalam Pembelajaran Menulis Cerita di Sekolah Dasar

“…Perubahan perilaku ini contohnya apabila siswa yang sebelumnya salah maka akan menjadi benar, siswa yang sebelumnya buruk maka akan menjadi baik, siswa yang sebelumnya tidak mengerti akan menjadi mengerti. Hal ini terjadi karena adanya proses interaksi dalam pembelajaran (Meiklejohn et al, 2021). Pembelajaran bertujuan agar siswanya mengalami perubahan perilaku tidak hanya mengetahui, tetapi siswa juga memahami dan mengaplikasikan ilmu yang telah didapatkan.…”

Psychosocial Determinants of Learners’ Poor Performance in South African Primary Schools: A Systematic Review Protocol

“…Researchers have intensively researched the causes of this problem and interventions to remedy it. The following were identi ed to be the leading causes: lack of parental support; lack of resources; poor teacher training; lack of school funding from the Department of Basic Education (DOE); Multi-grade; over-crowded classrooms et cetera (3,5,13,14). The DOE has drawn inspiration from research recommendations and initiated the following interventions: (1) The Annual National Assessments 2011, meant to improve learning outcomes in the education system; (2) Practical…”

‘It's like a compass which I use to find direction’: Findings and learning from an evaluation of an App designed to support the teaching of reading comprehension in rural and township schools in South Africa

“…The commonalities between both types of schools are poor resources, poor infrastructure and poverty. There have been a wide variety of intervention studies that have endeavoured to address the issues detailed in recent systematic reviews (Carter et al, 2023; Meiklejohn et al, 2021), but there is little evidence of interventions that have been effectively scaled up and out (Spaull et al, 2016), and so these have had limited impact on low attainment.…”