A Review of Research on the Quality and Use of Chemistry Textbooks

Abstract

The number of studies analyzing chemistry textbooks has steadily increased over the years and has notably surged in the past decade. In this literature review, we examine the research literature on chemistry textbooks. The review spans 40 years of research (from 1981 to 2021) and includes 79 studies published in over 20 different journals, analyzing secondary and postsecondary chemistry textbooks used in more than 17 countries. We synthesize the samples and methods used as well as the findings of the studies around chemistry textbooks. Based on this synthesis, we provide multiple concrete implications to improve the rigor of future studies of chemistry textbooks because most of the articles in our review lack a discussion of the limitations of their studies, half do not use any theoretical or analytical framework(s) to guide the design of their studies and the interpretation of findings, and a quarter do not specify the country of use for the textbooks in their samples. Additionally, we provide concrete recommendations for textbook developers to improve the quality of chemistry textbooks. Importantly, textbook developers need to ensure that their products are grounded in research and theory about student learning.

Enhancing Student Engagement and Outcomes by Utilizing Lightboard Videos to Facilitate a Flipped Classroom in General Chemistry

“…In response to these challenges, several scholars have effectively introduced instructional tools designed to foster student engagement with reading materials, employing strategies such as scaffolding, support, guidance, and structured reading assignments . Importantly, this study did not explore those tools due to constraints in time and resources, so this study does not contend that lightboard multimedia surpasses textbooks in information conveyance; rather, it suggests that the adoption of this video format may enhance student motivation and participation, serving as an adjunct to traditional textbook resources.…”

Textbook Sets Through the Perspective of the Orientation of the Intended Chemistry Curriculum for Primary and Secondary Schools

“…The use of textbooks has been a habitual means of supporting the effective teaching and learning of school subjects in primary and secondary schools, including the school subject chemistry. To support the quality of textbooks in chemistry education, much attention has been paid to the analysis of various aspects of the textbook, 66,67 for example, the analysis of the learning content, [68][69][70] the visual representations and their integration, 9,71,72 and the learning activities. [73][74][75] However, few textbook analyses focus on the aspect that textbooks convey not only explicit information but also hidden ideas, for example, the purpose of learning chemistry subject matter 13 and, as such, represent intended chemistry curriculum and direct to its orientation.…”

Toward Collaborative Dialogue: Unpacking the Researcher–Educator Divide to Advance Chemistry Education

“…We can leverage our existing communication pathways to move beyond knowledge dissemination toward knowledge mobilization. ,− The Journal of Chemical Education (JCE) publishes reviews and meta-analyses, which can be directed at educators − or curriculum developers but are most often directed at researchers. − JCE regularly publishes primers to facilitate chemistry content knowledge development − or improve researchers’ methodological knowledge. − However, primers that support domain-specific pedagogical development, such as the laboratory design primer by Neiles and Arnett (2021), are rare and can be difficult to find. In comparison, CBELife Sciences Education’s Current Insights feature curates and translates cross-disciplinary knowledge about teaching and learning in biology.…”