A research process for integrating Indigenous and scientific knowledge in cultural landscapes: principles and determinants of success in the Wet Tropics World Heritage Area, Australia

Abstract

It is widely accepted that Indigenous ecological knowledge (IEK) is potentially valuable for maintaining biodiversity within linked social-ecological systems, and cultural landscapes in particular. However, IEK is declining globally, along with biodiversity. Adaptive co-management frameworks incorporating both Indigenous and scientific knowledge systems have the capacity for greater success than frameworks embedded within a singular world view. A major challenge exists, however, in identifying pathways for the integration of these knowledge systems. The need to integrate both IEK and science into management is widely recognised; various approaches have been trialled but there are few successful examples. Cooperative research using joint learning is emerging as one potentially useful approach. Here we present an example of applying co-research in a cultural landscape in Australia, the Wet Tropics World Heritage Area, where we aimed to develop linked cultural and biophysical indicators of ecosystem condition. Our approach was founded on five stakeholder-defined core principles for research. The study revealed seven determinants of successful implementation within these principles: strong Indigenous governance; problem-framing and conceptualisation; relationship building; data collection and management; considerations of scale; agreed dissemination of results; and evaluation. We identify cooperative problem-framing as one of the most important determinants, and argue that by starting the co-research process with this task, co-research can assist the equitable convergence of IEK and contemporary natural resource management, thereby potentially enhancing social-ecological system resilience and sustainability.

Politically Engaged Geographical Research with the Community Sector: Is It Encouraged by Australia's Higher Education and Research Institutions?

“…Secondly, there could be a greater role for seed funding and open‐ended funding options to support the kind of action research that emphasises cooperative or collaborative problem‐framing and interactive scoping of projects, without the requirement for community organisations to contribute funds. A number of studies nominate the joint design of projects as a critical determinant of success in participatory projects involving indigenous people, at least (Cullen‐Unsworth et al ., , see also Casteldon et al ., ). Moreover, by valuing ‘slow research’, institutions will be better equipped to support the generation of long‐term commitments to participatory practices (mrs kinpaisby, ; Conlon et al ., ).…”

Community Biodiversity Inventories as Entry Points for Local Ecosystem Stewardship in a South African Communal Area

“…The process described in the preceding followed the essential elements of participatory action research advocated by Saija (2013) and Cullen-Unsworth et al (2012), among others. Realizing that equal power relations are difficult to achieve in rural settings such as Ncera (cf.…”

“…The process involves joint problem definition and identification and is characterized by equality between researchers and local people, constant reflection on the process and outcomes, mutual trust, and accessible and open communication (Cullen-Unsworth et al 2012). It enables communities to understand an issue or concern and take action to address it, which can empower people (Raymond and Cleary 2013).…”

Ecosystem-Based Adaptation for Food Security in the AIMS SIDS: Integrating External and Local Knowledge

“…Enhances the capacity of resource management organizations to respond proactively to uncertainty. Can contribute to trans-generational transfer of local knowledge through youth engagement [37]. Enables collaborators to develop a shared cross-cultural understanding of the research [37].…”

“…Adaptive Co-Management and Cooperative Research (utilised in many SIDS especially in the Pacific and Caribbean regions) [35][36][37].…”