A Randomized trial of a cognitive‐behavioral therapy and hypnosis intervention on positive and negative affect during breast cancer radiotherapy

Abstract

Breast cancer radiotherapy can be an emotionally difficult experience. Despite this, few studies have examined the effectiveness of psychological interventions to reduce negative affect, and none to date have explicitly examined interventions to improve positive affect among breast cancer radiotherapy patients. The present study examined the effectiveness of a multimodal psychotherapeutic approach, combining cognitive-behavioral therapy and hypnosis (CBTH), to reduce negative affect and increase positive affect in 40 women undergoing breast cancer radiotherapy. Participants were randomly assigned to receive either CBTH or standard care. Participants completed weekly self-report measures of positive and negative affect. Repeated and univariate analyses of variance revealed that the CBTH approach reduced levels of negative affect [F (1, 38) = 13.49; p = .0007], and increased levels of positive affect [F (1, 38) = 9.67; p = .0035, ω2 = .48], during the course of radiotherapy. Additionally, relative to control group, the CBTH group demonstrated significantly more intense positive affect [F (1,38) = 7.09; p = .0113, d = .71] and significantly less intense negative affect [F (1,38) = 10.30; p = .0027, d = .90] during radiotherapy. The CBTH group also had a significantly higher frequency of days where positive affect was greater than negative affect (85% of days assessed for the CBTH group versus 43% of the Control group) [F (1,38) = 18.16; p = .0001, d = 1.16]. Therefore, the CBTH intervention has the potential to improve the affective experience of women undergoing breast cancer radiotherapy.

Finding Positive Meaning After Loss: The Mediating Role of Reflection for Bereaved Individuals

“…Empirical literature suggests that a multimodal psychotherapy approach that combines cognitive behavior Finding Positive Meaning After Loss 253 therapy and hypnosis is effective in reducing negative affect and increasing positive affect during radiotherapy among breast cancer patients (Schnur et al, 2009). Further, in a longitudinal study, Moskowitz, Folkman, Collette, and Vittinghoff (1996) found that positive reappraisal was significantly associated with positive affect during AIDS-related care-giving and bereavement.…”

Anxiety and its time courses during radiotherapy for non-metastatic breast cancer: A longitudinal study

“…Although some studies have shown that radiotherapy is generally better accepted than what may be expected [3,4] and than other treatments [5], other studies have also shown that it can be associated with emotional distress [6][7][8] and especially anxiety [3,5,7,9]. Ten to twenty percent of patients with cancer experience anxiety before the start of radiotherapy [7] and 20-50% of patients feel anxious during the first days of treatment; these feelings tend to decrease throughout the course of treatment, although results have varied greatly across studies [7,10,11].…”

Coping with Illness and Psychotherapy of the Medically Ill

“…More recently the combination of CBT and hypnosis effectively decreased negative affect and improved positive affect in breast cancer patients receiving radiation therapy. 24 CBT changed maladaptive cognitions and behaviors in these patients while leading to more adaptive cognitive process; hypnosis (involving direct suggestion of decreasing negative affect and increasing positive affect) also led to improvement. In those infected with HIV, rates of depression are high, and co-morbidity is associated with increased rates of risky behaviors, poorer disease outcome (e.g., with a decreased CD4 count, an increased viral load, an increased progression to AIDS, and an increased mortality rate), and poor treatment adherence.…”