BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations predispose to cancer development, primarily through their loss of role in the repair of DNA double-strand breaks. They play a key role in homologous recombination repair, which is a conservative, error-free DNA repair mechanism. When mutated, other alternative, errorprone mechanisms for DNA repair take over, leading to genomic instability. Somatic mutations are rare in sporadic breast tumors, but expression of BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes can be downregulated in other mechanistic ways. These tumors have similar features in terms of their phenotypic and genotypic profiles, which are normally regulated by these genes, and mutations lead to defective DNA repair capacity, called "BRCAness." Attempts have been made to exploit this differentially expressed feature between tumors and normal tissues by treatment with DNA-damaging chemotherapy agents. Cells with this functional BRCA deficiency should be selectively susceptible to DNA-damaging drugs. Preclinical and early clinical (primarily retrospective) evidence supports this approach. In contrast, there is emerging evidence of relative resistance of tumors containing BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations (or BRCAness) to taxanes. In this review, we summarize the data supporting differentialchemotherapeuticsensitivityonthebasisofdefectiveDNA repair. If confirmed with available, clinically applicable techniques, this differential chemosensitivity could lead to treatment choices in breast cancer that have a more individualized biologic basis. The Oncologist 2013;18:909 -916 Implications for Practice: Women with germline BRCA mutations are more prone to develop breast, ovarian, and other cancers because of the inability to repair DNA damage effectively. These mutations cause a small minority of breast cancers, but studies have shown that such tumors respond better when treated with DNA-damaging chemotherapy agents. Evidence shows that nonmutated tumors also have defective DNA repair or "BRCAness" caused by other mechanisms and behave similarly to BRCAmutated tumors. Some clinical data support that tumors with BRCAness respond better to DNA-damaging chemotherapy. Preliminary data suggest that tumors with intact BRCA1 respond better to treatment with antitubulin agents. In this review, we discuss BRCAness and the clinical data supporting preferential responses to different chemotherapy agents. No standardized test to detect BRCAness exists yet, and various techniques are being developed because this test could affect chemotherapy choice.