A randomised controlled trial among cleaners-Effects on strength, balance and kinesiophobia

Abstract

BackgroundCleaners constitute a job group with poor health and low socioeconomic resources. Therefore, there is a great need for scientifically documented health promoting initiatives for cleaners. However, both workplace initiatives and high quality intervention studies are lacking. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of a 3-month workplace trial with interventions to improve physical or cognitive behavioural resources among cleaners.MethodsA cluster randomised controlled trial was conducted among 294 female cleaners from 9 workplaces. The participants were allocated to three groups: Physical coordination training (PCT, n = 95), Cognitive behavioural theory-based training (CBTr, n = 99) and Reference group (REF, n = 100). Interventions were conducted during work hours for an average of 1 hour/week. Muscle strength was measured by maximal voluntary contractions in trunk/extension, and shoulder abduction/elevation. Postural balance was measured on a force platform. Kinesiophobia was measured with Tampa Scale for Kinesiophobia. Test and questionnaires were completed at baseline and at 3-month follow-up and analyses followed the intention-to-treat (ITT) principle with last observation carried forward in case of missing data at follow-up. Reports and analyses are given on true observations as well.ResultsITT-analyses revealed that PCT improved strength of the trunk (p < .05) and postural balance (p < .05) compared to CBTr and REF. Based on true observations the strength and balance improvements corresponded to ~20% and ~16%, respectively. ITT-analyses showed that CBTr reduced kinesiophobia compared to PCT and REF (p < .05). Based on true observations, the improvement corresponded to a ~16% improvement.ConclusionThis workplace-based intervention study including PCT and CBTr among cleaners improved strength and postural balance from PCT, and kinesiophobia from CBTr. The improved strength, postural balance and kinesiophobia may improve the cleaners' tolerance for high physical work demands. Future studies should investigate the potential in the combination of PCT and CBTr in a workplace intervention.Trial registrationCurrent controlled trials ISRCTN96241850

Strength Training for Women as a Vehicle for Health Promotion at Work

“…The training programs also differed substantially in terms of normative standards, i.e., intensity of training stimuli, frequency of sessions, and amount of training. In at least three studies (20,24,27) the training schedule did not even meet the minimum standards of the World Health Organization (WHO) for strength-promoting exercise to prevent ill health (two sessions per week adding up to 75 min) (31).…”

“…After elimination of duplicates and scrutiny of study titles and abstracts, 68 articles remained for full-text analysis. Twelve publications fulfilled the selection criteria laid out in Table 1 (19)(20)(21)(22)(23)(24)(25)(26)(27)(28)(29)(30). The commonest reasons for exclusion were the absence of sex-specific analysis and the lack of muscle strength measurement.…”

Reduced Sickness Absence after a Physical Activity Intervention among Health Care Workers: One-Year Follow-Up of a Randomised Controlled Trial

“…Those participants having pain primarily related to the lower back participated in a programme with specific strengthening exercises corresponding to the strengthening exercises for the upper body. The standardised strengthening exercises for the lower back were exercises activating the rectus abdominis, erector spinae and oblique externus muscles for more than 60% of their maximal voluntary contraction [16,23]. During the intervention period, the training load was progressively increased.…”

“…pain situation, work ability, productivity, kinesiophobia and also outcomes measuring physical capacity. This physical activity intervention including both aerobic fitness training and strengthening exercises training was carefully chosen based on the results from previous research that have shown effective in other occupational groups [9,10,[15][16][17].…”

The Effect of a Physical Activity Program on Decreasing Physical Disability Indicated by Musculoskeletal Pain and Related Symptoms Among Workers: A Pilot Study

“…PA interventions to improve muscle strength, stretch, and postural control, e.g., co-ordination training, may be particularly relevant for preventing osteoarticular deterioration in workers [13].…”