A qualitative synthesis of factors influencing maintenance of lifestyle behaviour change in individuals with high cardiovascular risk

Abstract

BackgroundManagement of cardiovascular risk factors includes commitment from patients to adhere to prescribed medications and adopt healthy lifestyles. Unfortunately many fail to take up and maintain the four key healthy behaviours (not smoking, having a balanced diet, limiting alcohol consumption and being more active). Five factors (beliefs, knowledge, transport and other costs, emotions, and friends and family support) are known to predict uptake of lifestyle behaviour change. The key factors influencing maintenance of healthy lifestyles are not known but would be helpful to support the development of relapse prevention programmes for this population. Our review aimed to clarify the main patient perceived factors thought to influence maintenance of changed healthy lifestyles.MethodsWe performed a systematic review of qualitative observational studies and applied the principles of content synthesis and thematic analysis to extract reported factors (barriers and facilitators) considered by individuals to be influential in maintaining changed healthy lifestyle behaviours. Factors were then organised into an existing framework of higher order categories which was followed by an analysis of the interrelationships between factors to identify key themes.ResultsTwenty two studies met our inclusion criteria. Participants reported barriers and facilitators within 13 categories, the majority of which were facilitators. The most commonly reported influences were those relating to social support (whether provided formally or informally), beliefs (about the self or the causes and management of poor health, and the value of maintaining lifestyle behaviours), and other psychological factors (including attitude, thinking and coping styles, and problem solving skills). Physical activity was the most commonly investigated behaviour in four categories, but overall, the main barriers and facilitators were related to a range of behaviours. Through analysis of the interrelationships between factors within categories, ‘social support’, ‘education and knowledge’, and ‘beliefs and emotions’ were all considered key themes.ConclusionsOur review suggests that for the most part, factors that influence lifestyle change are also important for maintaining healthy behaviours. This indicates that addressing these barriers and facilitators within lifestyle support programmes would also be of value in the longer-term.

Adherence challenges encountered in an intervention programme to combat chronic non-communicable diseases in an urban black community, Cape Town

“…Participants also questioned the benefits of health interventions probably because of clearly visible consequences of not conforming to recommended actions not being disseminated. Similar findings were reported in a recent study by Murray et al (2013) where participants did not conform to health interventions because of their disbelief in health messages. Financial constraints, fear for personal safety, lack of transport and access to facilities where CNCD intervention programmes were offered also detracted from participants' ability to implement and adhere to CNCD intervention health messages.…”

“…However, many adults still struggle to implement and adhere to healthy lifestyle behaviours (Murray et al, 2013).…”

Patients’ responses to the communication of vascular risk in primary care: a qualitative study

“…Second, ensure that the discussion is held face to face to make it easier to develop a good understanding of the patient's perspective. During consultations with patients who have a 'non-committed' response style, include a discussion about any barriers to lifestyle change (Murray et al, 2012). We acknowledge that these recommendations may not be easy to put into practice, but we found people to be very open about these issues during their interviews.…”

Importance of giving health education regarding lifestyle modification and perceived barriers: focus group discussion among community health workers of slum of Kolkata, India

“…Few studies had shown that even walking for 20 minutes 3 times a week can significantly reduce the complications and effectively manage the conditions similar description was given by health workers in this study. [6][7][8] The most important barrier in doing physical activity is lack of time due to their household work. Most of the participants opined that dietary modification as the basic preventive measure, regarding this; barrier was lack of knowledge about salt restriction and over intake of junk foods, as they are easily available and affordable at slums.…”