A Qualitative Insight into Gendered Vulnerabilities: A Case Study of the Shishper GLOF in Hunza Valley, Pakistan

Abstract

Gendered vulnerability from women’s point of view has gained popularity in disaster studies in recent decades especially in the Global South. The positioning of women in society during normal times gives rise to vulnerabilities that are revealed when a disaster strikes. These vulnerabilities are often deep-rooted in societal makeup, cultural and traditional norms, and the economic fabric of society. In the context of Pakistan, the role of women in disaster risk reduction programs is still an under-researched area. In this paper, the gendered vulnerability progression in one of the mountain rural communities of Hassanabad in Hunza Valley (Northern Pakistan) is analyzed post-Shishper glacier lake outburst flood (GLOF) in 2019 and 2020. The study uses empirical qualitative data. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with men and women of different age groups within Hassanabad village. A thematic gendered analysis unveiled several interlinked social, economic, and institutional vulnerabilities. The gendered transitional phase of Hassanabad society positively indicates women’s involvement in different spheres of life, including disaster management and mitigation. However, the lack of gender consideration on a formal institutional level exacerbates the gendered vulnerabilities in Hassanabad village. The case study of Hassanabad demonstrated that women not only have an awareness of hazards but are also willing to participate proactively in disaster mitigation activities. Therefore, to reduce community vulnerability and yield long-term positive outcomes of disaster management and mitigation strategies, women must be involved at the formal institutional levels.

Women in Disaster Policy: A Bibliometric Mapping of the Research Literature 2015-2023

“…The discourse regarding disaster risk reduction is tightly related to the vulnerability discourse, which is concerned with how disasters unequally affect women and men due to vulnerability. The vulnerability of women already existed in pre-disaster due to power relations, social hierarchies, and gender roles (Khalid et al, 2021;Trentin et al, 2023). Accordingly, reciprocally have a significant relationship with gender equality (Haque et al, 2022).…”

Exploring the Paradox of Population Growth and Food Resources in Punjab – Pakistan: Reassessment in the Light of Malthusian Theory

“…Classified as an N-11 nation, it has the potential for future economic growth. Its large population faces poverty, malnutrition, inadequate healthcare, education facilities and extremely bad housing conditions (Khalid & Khalid, 2014).…”

“…It leads the other provinces by producing 75.6 per cent of the country's wheat, 59 percent of its rice, and 67 percent of its total food production and 72 percent of its sugarcane. However, 52.9 percent of the country's total population lives in Punjab, which had a population growth rate of 2.1 percent per annum growth rate during 2017 (Khalid & Khalid, 2014).…”