A Positive Emotional-Based Meditation but Not Mindfulness-Based Meditation Improves Emotion Regulation

Abstract

Among the various strategies for modulating the components of the emotional responses, the cognitive reappraisal and distraction are highlighted in current researches. As indicated in recent studies, the capacity for emotional regulation can be improved by mindfulness meditation practicing. This practice usually offers benefits to people’s cognitive functioning and aims to improve a characteristic that is intrinsic to every human being: the ability to turn attention to the present moment. Importantly, positive emotions might also be effective on emotional regulation and several meditation practices make use of it. Thus, we aimed to compare two meditation modalities: one focused on attention only (mindfulness) and another focused-on attention toward positive emotions [Twin Hearts Meditation (THM)]. Ninety healthy subjects without any previous experience in meditation were enrolled in this experiment. Of these participants, 30 were submitted to the mindfulness practice with full attention on the observation of thoughts; 30 to the THM; and 30 to a control group (no meditation practice). After one session of meditation, all the participants completed emotional regulation task judging the valence and arousal of pictures with emotional content. In addition to the behavioral data, the participants’ psychophysiological measures were recorded via electrocardiography (ECG). The results demonstrate a greater efficacy of THM in suppressing the negative valence of the negative pictures and amplifying the valence of the positive ones. No effect of meditation was observed for the ECG. Our findings indicate that contemplative meditation (THM) can positively influence the emotion regulation ability, even when performed by non-meditators and only once. However, in mindfulness meditation this same immediate effect was not found. Our findings reveal that faster effects of meditation practices can be obtained by practices that considers either the attentional processing and the positive emotions.

Perceived Stress and Life Satisfaction Among Chinese Clinical Nursing Teachers: A Moderated Mediation Model of Burnout and Emotion Regulation

“…Secondly, given the mediation role of ES, this study may inform initiatives to carry out ER training (ERT) to strengthen stress management. Generally, ERT incorporates techniques including but not limited to mindfulness ( 49 ), cognitive-behavioral therapy ( 50 ), and emotion-focused mediation ( 51 ) in order to improve ER skills to deal with stressful situations. ERT is expected to reduce or eliminate burnout syndromes and improve life satisfaction among workers with highly occupational stress such as clinical teaching nurses.…”

The Effect of Short-Term Mindfulness Training on the Emotional State of College Students with Different Levels of Mindfulness: Evidence from Neurophysiological Signals

“…Erisman and Roemer (2010) found that after short-term mindfulness training, participants showed more positive emotions responding to positive emotional materials. In Valim's et al (2019) experiment, he found that this effect only existed in short-term mindfulness based on positive emotion awareness. The training based on concentration has no effect.…”

“…After each meditation, participants' HR and BP were significantly reduced. Valim et al (2019) investigated the impact of short-term mindfulness training in different types on emotional states, and measured the heart rate at the same time. The result showed no significant difference in heart rate under any condition.…”

Mindfulness e regulação emocional: uma revisão sistemática de literatura

“…Entretanto, este estudo não encontrou evidências empíricas de que mindfulness disposicional que a meditação baseada em mindfulness favorece uma postura de maior descentralização (uma maneira mais desprendida de se relacionar com os próprios pensamentos) do que as outras técnicas (80) . Em um estudo, porém, foi apontado que a meditação dos corações gêmeos foi mais eficaz para a emergência de afetos positivos do que a meditação baseada em mindfulness (81) . É importante considerar os objetivos…”