A participatory community case study of periurban coastal flood vulnerability in southern Ecuador

Abstract

BackgroundPopulations in coastal cities are exposed to increasing risk of flooding, resulting in rising damages to health and assets. Adaptation measures, such as early warning systems for floods (EWSFs), have the potential to reduce the risk and impact of flood events when tailored to reflect the local social-ecological context and needs. Community perceptions and experiences play a critical role in risk management, since perceptions influence people’s behaviors in response to EWSFs and other interventions.MethodsWe investigated community perceptions and responses in flood-prone periurban areas in the coastal city of Machala, Ecuador. Focus groups (n = 11) were held with community members (n = 65 people) to assess perceptions of flood exposure, sensitivity, adaptive capacity, and current alert systems. Discussions were audio recorded, transcribed, and coded by topic. Participatory maps were field validated, georeferenced, and digitized using GIS software. Qualitative data were triangulated with historical government information on rainfall, flood events, population demographics, and disease outbreaks.ResultsFlooding was associated with seasonal rainfall, El Niño events, high ocean tides, blocked drainage areas, overflowing canals, collapsed sewer systems, and low local elevation. Participatory maps revealed spatial heterogeneity in perceived flood risk across the community. Ten areas of special concern were mapped, including places with strong currents during floods, low elevation areas with schools and homes, and other places that accumulate stagnant water. Sensitive populations included children, the elderly, physically handicapped people, low-income families, and recent migrants. Flood impacts included damages to property and infrastructure, power outages, and the economic cost of rebuilding/repairs. Health impacts included outbreaks of infectious diseases, skin infections, snakebite, and injury/drowning. Adaptive capacity was weakest during the preparation and recovery stages of flooding. Participants perceived that their capacity to take action was limited by a lack of social organization, political engagement, and financial capital. People perceived that flood forecasts were too general, and instead relied on alerts via social media.ConclusionsThis study highlights the challenges and opportunities for climate change adaptation in coastal cities. Areas of special concern provide clear local policy targets. The participatory approach presented here (1) provides important context to shape local policy and interventions in Ecuador, complimenting data gathered through standard flood reports, (2) provides a voice for marginalized communities and a mechanism to raise local awareness, and (3) provides a research framework that can be adapted to other resource-limited coastal communities at risk of flooding.

Assessing Flood Vulnerability Index for Policy Implications Towards Flood Risk Management Along the Atlantic Coast of Limbe, Cameroon

“…The increasing practice of building on watercourses and wetlands, indiscriminate dumping and silting of drains has exacerbated the perennial urban floods in Limbe. This result confirms the findings of [46,47] who highlighted that increase incidence of floods is because of the low-lying nature of the land, high rainfall intensity and duration, deposition of sediments in storm drains Field results show that 31.4% of households in Down Beach are not aware of flood risk zones as compared to only 14.6% in Cassava Farm. Poor knowledge of flood risk zones can result in the construction of houses in zones that are prone to floods.…”

Climate change adaptation: the case of coastal communities in the Philippines

“…As a result of their exposure to flooding, they had to live in unsafe conditions that adversely affected their livelihood and living conditions. As observed by Tauzer et al (2019), sensitive populations are most likely to suffer from increased risk of infectious diseases caused by mobility limitations and lower immunity levels. Low-wage income earners were also perceived to be socially vulnerable because of limited opportunities for labor during disasters.…”

Climate services for health: From global observations to local interventions

“…12,13 We used Bayesian hierarchical models of monthly cases of dengue between 2002 and 2014 (Figure S1A) and malaria between 1990 and 2015 (Figure S1B) for the city of Machala, in southern Ecuador, a city at risk of the health impacts of climate change. 15 Prior studies found that dengue and malaria transmission were sensitive to changes in climate in this region. 12,13 We compared five global products of monthly mean temperature and precipitation, with local weather station data, to investigate the impact of local climate variation on these two vector-borne diseases.…”