A novel Zende’s-TOPSIS method towards estimation of measurement uncertainty in hole diameters

Abstract

The 'Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS)' is one of the best methods for 'Multi-Criteria Decision-Making' and 'Multi-Objective Optimization'. The traditional TOPSIS method determines the best alternative under fixed conditions. However, it cannot determine the best upper limit and lowest limit values. This work explains the detailed methodology of the newly developed Zende's-TOPSIS method which was used to estimate the measurement uncertainty in hole diameters. Four identical holes and one center hole in an industrial component were measured to investigate measurement uncertainty. According to the experimental results, Zende's-TOPSIS method performed better than the traditional TOPSIS method. The percentage improvement in the Zende's-TOPSIS method over the traditional TOPSIS method ranges from 0.0209% to 0.3053%. Using Zende's-TOPSIS method, the percentage maximum measurement uncertainty for four identical holes varies from 0.8067% to 1.0222%, whereas for the center hole, it varies from 0.5261% to 0.5576%. Similarly, the percentage minimum measurement uncertainty for four identical holes varies from 0.3839% to 0.6406%, whereas for the center hole, it varies from 0.4014% to 0.4041%. The proposed method is also capable of estimating the machined tolerances of the component, which ranges from 18.0772 mm to 18.1708 mm for four identical holes and 49.2215 mm to 49.2572 mm for the center hole. The proposed method can solve various 'Multi-Objective Optimization' problems.