“…Other game engines like Unreal Engine and Unity also contribute to this area. Provided updated BIM and GIS integration environment for smart city [10,31] IoT-based data acquisition framework BIM, IoT developed a framework in using IoT devices and networks to establish a data acquisition system for buildings (and potentially community or city) [21] HDF-based BIM and GIS integration approach BIM, GIS an approach that created a city DT with enhanced storage efficiency [23] Online digital twin interaction diagram for smart city BIM, IoT indicated different layers of information in the city and, platform was built for urban planning for the public [26] An urban digital twin 3D model BIM, LiDAR, GIS, wind simulation data etc 3D model of the city was developed for citizen participatory and environmental simulation [9] A Digital geoTwin for City Information Modelling (CIM) BIM, GIS, other data e.g., census, economic, energy in the future provided a strategy to create the geoTwin integrating BIM/GIS data as the basis of CIM [24] A system of DTs for the City of Zurich BIM, GIS, Open Government Data developed an urban digital twin environment for multiple city purposes [32] A web-based environment of realistic BIM and GIS information BIM, GIS, aerial photogrammetry provided the integrated data environment for cadastral management [25] A smart city digital twin architecture Semantic information of city management e.g., urban planning, land use, energy, emergency supported knowledge representation and reasoning with machine learning and tested with energy use analysis [27] Virtual Singapore platform multiple…”