A New Theoretical Framework regarding the Application and Reliability of Photographic Evidence

Abstract

The application of photographic evidence within forensic science and the judicial system has been in practice since the birth of photography itself. However, with more than a century of application, the compelling nexus between photography and physical evidence has no clear theoretical framework that explains this pivotal relationship. From a pragmatic perspective, this article proposes a new theoretical framework that focuses on the reliability of photographic evidence as the central theme of the model. It provides a description of physical evidence as various modes of inquiry and introduces the concept that photographic evidence reliability should be considered based on the source of the photographic material. The theoretical framework introduces taxonomical descriptors of photographic evidence including: (1) analyse, (2) document, (3) describe (visual narrative), and (4) witness forms of photographic modes of inquiry. Visual culture intellectual John Berger 1 said: 'At one level there are no photographs which can be denied. All photographs have a status of fact. What has to be examined is in what way photography can and cannot give meaning to facts.' This article will examine the critical concepts regarding how photographic evidence can be considered as reliable when used as physical evidence.

Literasi Visual Dalam Imej Digital Fotografi Forensik Penyiasatan (Visual Literacy on Photographic Images in Digital Forensic Investigation)

“…Masyarakat moden telah menjadi taasub dengan penggunaan imej fotografi di dalam kehidupan mereka yang mempunyai fungsi untuk merakamkan, mengabadikan atau menceritakan suatu peristiwa. Imej Fotografi sering digunakan oleh media cetak dan televisyen yang berperanan secara berkesan untuk melaporkan berita dan cerita (Porter, 2011). Roland Barthes (1980) telah menulis dan mengesahkan bahawa imej fotografi telah bertindak sebagai mesej yang berkesan.…”

“…Imej fotografi juga boleh memberikan tindak balas terhadap undang-undang sebagai dokumentasi bahan bukti dan memberikan peningkatan tahap komunikasi visual dalam penyiasatan jenayah. Dalam erti kata, sains forensik menggunakan imej fotografi untuk merakam dan mengkaji bukti, akses fotografi, dan yang terbaru ialah penambahbaikan teknologi pengimejan digital (Porter, 2011). Rakaman tempat kejadian dengan cara ini akan membolehkan mahkamah untuk melihat tempat kejadian dalam saiz yang kecil dan terkawal.…”

Data Recovery from Proprietary Formatted Cctv Hard Disks

“…The primary goal of digital CCTV forensics is to ensure the reliability and admissibility of video evidence [4]. To reduce the risk of digital evidence being called into question in judicial proceedings, it is important to have a rigorous methodology and procedures for conducting digital forensic examinations.…”

What is the value of forensic science? An overview of the effectiveness of forensic science in the Australian criminal justice system project

“…What do we actually know about the impact of forensic science on the criminal justice system in general and on criminal investigations in particular? Indeed, a number of recent studies have emphasised the need to assess the contribution of the role and impact of scientific evidence in criminal case processing 5 and the impact of forensic evidence on various stages of the criminal justice process [6][7][8] . This includes the need to assess how new technologies affect policing and whether policing practices become effective as a consequence 9 .…”