A New Normal: Assessment Outcomes and Recommendations for Virtual Versus In-Person Curricula in Post-COVID-19 Times

Abstract

Introduction COVID-19 response efforts that began in March 2020 prompted an urgent need to transition medical education from an in-person to a virtual format. Our aim is to provide evaluation of a virtual platform for a fully integrated curriculum to provide future guidance in teaching methods. Materials and Methods We used summative assessments and course evaluations from pre- and post-transition from in-person to virtual delivery of educational content to measure the impacts of this transition on student performance and perceptions. Additionally, we surveyed students about their in-person versus online educational preferences. Results There were no statistically significant differences in student knowledge acquisition as assessed by weighted averages of summative assessments when comparing an in-person to a virtual educational platform. While the transition to virtual learning was initially well-received by students, our studied cohorts gave lower scores for the overall learning experience after prolonged virtual learning ( p < 0.001). Students had a strong preference that anatomy and other group sessions should be delivered in-person. There was no strong preference whether other learning modalities should be given in-person or virtually. Conclusions Although student knowledge acquisition remained stable on a virtual platform, the student learning experience varied. We recommend that when returning to a new normal after COVID-19 restrictions are lifted, sessions that require 3-dimensional or group learning should remain in-person, while other educational activities may be offered on a virtual platform and that, whenever virtual learning is employed, attention be paid to ensuring ongoing social and academic engagement between learners and faculty.

Application of virtual simulation in clinical skills and operation courses

“…The construction of the current VSO program has taken shape. Integrating VSOs more deeply into the curriculum and creating a first-class VSO course will be a new trend in the reform of clinical medicine teaching ( 17 ).…”

Moving from tangibility toward digitalization: investigating team dynamics and facilitator support among medical students in conventional and digital small-group tutorials

“…An important finding in this study was that higher teamwork satisfaction predicted students’ preference for choosing digital SGT in the future (Table 6 ). A recent study suggested that preferences for digital education was relatively low for group learning processes compared to in-person one during the COVID-19 period, especially during prolonged digital learning [ 34 ]. We believe that this phenomenon likely resulted from the suboptimal teamwork satisfaction in under-prepared digital group learning sessions.…”

What’s on your Mind? Impact of Online Education on Students’ Mental Wellness

“…First-week online education boomed (Babbar & Gupta, 2022). Data showed students appreciated the setting (Cowan et al, 2022). Learning faded over time.…”