A New Framework for Assessing the Sustainability Reporting Disclosure of Water Utilities

Abstract

Sustainability reporting is becoming more and more widespread among companies aiming at disclosing their contribution to sustainable development and gaining legitimacy from stakeholders. This is more significant for firms operating in a public services' context and mainly when supplying a fundamental public resource, like water utilities. While the literature on sustainability reporting in the water sector is scant, there is an increasing need to study the usefulness and quality of its sustainability disclosures to adequately inform the stakeholders about the activities of water utilities to protect this fundamental resource and general sustainable development. This article presents a novel assessment framework based on a scoring technique and an empirical analysis on the sustainability reports of Italian water utilities carried out through it. The results highlight a low level of disclosure on the sustainability indicators suggested by the main sustainability reporting guidelines (Global Reporting Initiative, (GRI), and Sustainability Accounting Standard Board, (SASB)); most companies tend to disclose only qualitative information and fail to inform about some material aspects of water management, such as water recycled, network resilience, water sources, and effluent quality. These findings indicate that sustainability reporting is mainly considered as a communication tool, rather than a performance measurement and an accountability tool, but also suggest the need for a new and international industry-specific sustainability reporting standard.

Mandatory Sustainability Reporting in Germany: Does Size Matter?

“…Any country seeking to understand the impact of mandatory sustainability reporting on its organizations will more easily be able to provide support where needed and thus avoid possibly imbalanced development among firms over the long term. Countries could thus also harness sustainability reporting as it provides the chance to improve corporate transparency and accountability [99]. Additionally, in France, for example, it might be interesting to understand whether abidance by the law is increased compared to previous national reporting frameworks (e.g., cf.…”

Comparative Review of Corporate Social Responsibility of Energy Utilities and Sustainable Energy Development Trends in the Baltic States

“…Some studies analyzed CSR practices and their implications in other public sectors [23][24][25][26][27]. The majority of studies dealt with the CSR of public sector enterprises and their impacts in the water sector [28][29][30][31][32][33][34][35]. The main areas of investigation were the drivers of CSR [36][37][38][39], as well as the impacts of CSR practices on consumer perceptions and loyalty [40][41][42][43][44][45][46][47][48][49][50].…”

An Investigation of Global Reporting Initiative Performance Indicators in Corporate Sustainability Reports: Greek, Italian and Spanish Evidence

“…A small number of studies have investigated the performance indicators disclosed in CSR reports focussing or on a single typology of indicators [11,[15][16][17][18], or on indicators within the full content of the CSR reports [19][20][21] or only on the GRI indicators disclosed in SRs [22][23][24]. This latter category of research is less rich in contributions from the accounting and reporting literature.…”