A National Study of the Influence of the Community College Pathway on Female Students’ STEM Baccalaureate Success

Abstract

Objective: This study examines the role of community colleges in closing the gender gap in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) by studying whether beginning at a community college improves the likelihood of female students earning their bachelor’s degree in STEM. Method: Using nationally representative data, we apply a propensity score matching approach to reduce the selection bias associated with a prospective student’s decision to begin at a community college rather than a 4-year institution. For each gender group, we employ a logistic regression model to estimate the influence of the community college pathway on STEM bachelor’s degree attainment. Results: We find that enrolling initially at a community college has a negative influence on students’ bachelor’s degree attainment in STEM for the pooled sample and male subsample. However, this finding does not hold for the female subsample, indicating that female students who attend community college before transferring to a 4-year institution are not less likely to obtain a bachelor’s degree in STEM. Although additional analyses indicate that community college starters are more likely to drop out from a STEM bachelor’s degree program, the impact only exists for the pooled and male samples but not for female students. Contributions: Considering the significant efforts community colleges have devoted toward creating a suitable environment for female students in which to thrive, this study provides empirical evidence that community colleges have the potential to narrow the STEM achievement gap between gender groups and provide significant utility for female students seeking a bachelor’s degree in STEM fields.

Racism, sexism and disconnection: contrasting experiences of Black women in STEM before and after transfer from community college

“…Research on the success of women, in general, has found that community colleges provide an intellectually rigorous and comfortable learning environment (Hu & Ortagus, 2019;Jackson & Laanan, 2011;Jackson et al, 2013;Jackson et al, 2013;Perez-Felkner et al, 2019;St. Rose & Hill, 2013;Starobin et al, 2016), where women are more likely to take advantage of student services than men (Miller et al, 2006) and receive more benefit from the learning and advising experience (Packard et al, 2011;Starobin & Laanan, 2008).…”

Diversifying STEM pathways: A look into upward transfer students’ sense of belonging in computing

“…Importantly, students who are able to successfully transfer often see high levels of success. For example, research reveals that attending a community college prior to transfer has no impact on women's STEM bachelor's degree attainment (Hu & Ortagus, 2019). Thus, STEM upward transfer students represent a talented group, and understanding the needs and successes of students who follow degree pathways through community colleges is critical.…”

Animation Teaching Materials about Female Mathematicians—With Émilie du Châtelet as an Example

“…Furthermore, females are inclined not to recognize their success is driven by ability and interest when facing gender stereotypes in subjects (Chen & Suen, 2006). However, studies believed their failure is caused by incompetence and thus enhanced the idea of gender stereotype (Burkley & Blanton, 2007;Huang, 2007;Wang, Chan, Soffa, & Nachman, 2017;Hu & Ortagus, 2019).…”