A narrative review comparing clinical effectiveness of commonly used uterine balloon tamponade devices for postpartum haemorrhage management in India

Abstract

Background: World Health Organisation recommends using Uterine Balloon Tamponade (UBT) for refractory atonic postpartum haemorrhage (PPH) management provided treatment protocols and surgical recourse is possible. Methods: This review collated literature from three electronic databases between January 2010 to December 2019 to compare clinical effectiveness, safety and use related parameters for condom-UBT, Bakri balloon and Every Second Matters (ESM) UBT devices used in India. Results: Thirty-three eligible studies reported effectiveness in managing all PPH causes ranging from 84.2% to 98.3% for condom-UBT and from 65.3% to 94.8% for Bakri-UBT. Three ESM-UBT studies reported PPH survival rates of 94% to 97.4%. Mean UBT effectiveness in controlling atonic PPH was 92.3% for condom-UBT, 84.3% for Bakri-UBT and 97.3% for ESM-UBT. Condom-UBT and Bakri-UBT were comparable across parameters whereas limited ESM-UBT evidence reported success in preventing maternal deaths. Conclusions: For limitations and heterogeneity in methodology and outcome parameters with existing evidence, a robust comparative RCT between UBT devices in India is recommended.