A molecular phylogeny for the oldest (nonditrysian) lineages of extant Lepidoptera, with implications for classification, comparative morphology and life‐history evolution

Abstract

Within the insect order Lepidoptera (moths and butterflies), the so-called nonditrysian superfamilies are mostly species-poor but highly divergent, offering numerous synapomorphies and strong morphological evidence for deep divergences. Uncertainties remain, however, and tests of the widely accepted morphological framework using other evidence are desirable. The goal of this paper is to test previous hypotheses of nonditrysian phylogeny against a data set consisting of 61 nonditrysian species plus 20 representative Ditrysia and eight outgroups (Trichoptera), nearly all sequenced for 19 nuclear genes (up to 14 700 bp total). We compare our results in detail with those from previous studies of nonditrysians, and review the morphological evidence for and against each grouping The major conclusions are as follows. (i) There is very strong support for Lepidoptera minus Micropterigidae and Agathiphagidae, here termed Angiospermivora, but no definitive resolution of the position of Agathiphagidae, although support is strongest for alliance with Micropterigidae, consistent with another recent molecular study. (ii) There is very strong support for Glossata, which excludes Heterobathmiidae, but weak support for relationships among major homoneurous clades. Eriocraniidae diverge first, corroborating the morphological clade Coelolepida, but the morphological clades Myoglossata and Neolepidoptera are never monophyletic in the molecular trees; both are contradicted by strong support for Lophocoronoidea + Hepialoidea, the latter here including Correspondence: Charles Mitter, †Deceased 6 December 2014. No conflicts of interest were discovered. © 2015 The Royal Entomological Society 671 672 J. C. Regier et al.Mnesarchaeoidea syn.n. (iii) The surprising grouping of Acanthopteroctetidae + Neopseustidae, although weakly supported here, is consistent with another recent molecular study. (iv) Heteroneura is very strongly supported, as is a basal split of this clade into Nepticuloidea + Eulepidoptera. Relationships within Nepticuloidea accord closely with recent studies based on fewer genes but many more taxa. (v) Eulepidoptera are split into a very strongly supported clade consisting of Tischeriidae + Palaephatidae + Ditrysia, here termed Euheteroneura, and a moderately supported clade uniting Andesianidae with Adeloidea. (vi) Relationships within Adeloidea are strongly resolved and Tridentaformidae fam.n. is described for the heretofore problematic genus Tridentaforma Davis, which is strongly supported in an isolated position within the clade. (vii) Within Euheteroneura, the molecular evidence is conflicting with respect to the sister group to Ditrysia, but strongly supports paraphyly of Palaephatidae. We decline to change the classification, however, because of strong morphological evidence supporting palaephatid monophyly. (viii) We review the life histories and larval feeding habits of all nonditrysian families and assess the implications of our results for hypotheses about early lepidopteran phytophagy. The first host record for ...

New genes from old: asymmetric divergence of gene duplicates and the evolution of development

“…It may be futile to search for simple explanations for why there are so many butterflies and moth species, but some contributing factors can be postulated. In particular, butterflies and moths most likely radiated in concert with the diversification of flowering plants [47], with the larvae of each species evolving adaptations to allow phytophagy on (or in) leaves, usually in the face of intense chemical defence from the plants [48]. Lepidoptera have evolved sophisticated and adaptable detoxification systems to overcome such defences [49,50].…”

Catapterix tianshanica sp. n. – the second species of the genus from the Palaearctic Region (Lepidoptera, Acanthopteroctetidae)

“…Another species was found to be a miner in leaves of Ribes (Grossulariaceae) (Regier et al 2015, Eiseman 2016. In the western Tianshan Mts.…”

A revised checklist of Nepticulidae fossils (Lepidoptera) indicates an Early Cretaceous origin

“…Nepticulidae form a Superfamily, Nepticuloidea, together with the Opostegidae, of which the latter lack known fossils. Opostegidae also are herbivores, but, to the extent that larval habits are known, the majority of extant species create stem-or bark-mines, often consuming cambium tissue; very few species construct mines in leaves (Regier et al 2015). Larval traces of mines in bark or cambium are difficult to find and recognize, even in modern live hosts, and the absence of their traces in the fossil record is not surprising.…”

“…Nepticulidae commonly are known as pygmy moths and constitute a species rich, basal family within lepidopteran phylogeny, and consequently may offer a series of calibration points of both practical and theoretical importance (see Regier et al 2015). The family comprises some of the smallest adult Lepidoptera known, and is found on all continents except Antarctica.…”