The cytochrome P450 enzyme, CYP199A4 from Rhodopseudomonas palustris strain HaA2, is able to oxidize parasubstituted benzoic acids. This enzyme was used to compare aromatic versus aliphatic C−H bond oxidation, common reactions catalyzed by the P450 superfamily of heme monooxygenases. CYP199A4 was able to bind 4-phenylbenzoic acid and 4cyclohexylbenzoic acid, and the crystal structures demonstrated that both substrates are bound within the active site in a similar fashion. Despite this, while 4-cyclohexylbenzoic acid was efficiently hydroxylated, no detectable enzyme catalyzed oxidation of the aromatic 4-phenylbenzoic acid was observed. The selectivity of 4-cyclohexylbenzoic acid oxidation favored C−H bond abstraction at one of the β-sites in an enantioselective fashion (66%, 95:5 er), over C−H bond abstraction at the benzylic position (33%). In addition, unlike the oxidation of smaller alkyl-substituted benzoic acids (4-ethyl-and 4-isopropyl-), little or no desaturation of the cyclohexyl ring to give an alkene was detected (∼1%). Molecular dynamics simulations suggested that the cyclohexyl ring of 4cyclohexylbenzoic acid was able to achieve a suitable orientation to enable efficient C−H bond abstraction and oxidation by the enzyme at the expected positions. In contrast, when the distance and angle of attack were considered, the alignment of the phenyl ring of 4-phenylbenzoic acid rarely attained a productive geometry for aromatic oxidation to occur. Overall, these results illustrate the chemoselectivity that may arise due to the different geometrical requirements for efficient aromatic oxidation versus aliphatic C− H bond hydroxylation by cytochrome P450 enzymes.