A model of policing strategy choice

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to develop a method for the discovery of knowledge in emergency response databases based on police incident reports, generating information that identifies local criminal demands that allow the selection of the appropriate policing strategies portfolio to solve the problem. Design/methodology/approach The developed model uses a methodology for the discovery of knowledge involving text mining techniques using Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) integrated with the ELECTRE I multicriteria method. Findings The developed method allowed the identification of the most common criminal demands that occurred from January 1 to December 31, 2016, in the policing areas studied. One of the crimes does not occur homogeneously in a particular locality. In this study, it was initially observed that 40 per cent of the crimes identified in the Integrated Public Safety Area 5, or AISP-5, (historical city center of RJ) had no correlation with AISP-19 (Copacabana - RJ), and 33 per cent of crimes crimes in AISP-19 were not identified in AISP-5. This finding guided the second part of the method that sought to identify which portfolio of policing strategies would be most appropriate for the identified demands. In this sense, using the ELECTRE I method, eight different scenarios were constructed where it can be identified that for each specific criminal demand set there is a set of policing strategies to be applied. Research limitations/implications The collected data represent the social dynamics of neighbourhoods in the central and southern zones of the city of Rio de Janeiro during the specific period from January 2013 to December 2016. This limitation implies that the results cannot be generalised to areas with different characteristics. Practical implications The developed methodology contributes in a complementary way to the identification of criminal practices and their characteristics based on reports of police occurrences stored in emergency response databases. The knowledge generated through the identification of criminal demands allows law enforcement decision makers to evaluate and choose among the available policing strategies, which best suit the reality they study, and produce the reduction of criminal indices. Social implications It is possible to infer that by choosing appropriate strategies to combat local crime, the proposed model will increase the population’s sense of safety through an effective reduction in crime. Originality/value The originality of the study lies in the integration of text mining techniques, LDA and the ELECTRE I method for detecting crime in a given location based on crime reports stored in emergency response databases, enabling identification and choice, from customized policing strategies to particular criminal demands.

Assessing the Value of Black Friday Promotions: An Analysis of Instagram Users’ Sentiments and Behavioral Responses

“…Our research approach is divided into three sequential phases. The first phase of analysis incorporates the LDA model, following the guidelines established by Basilio et al (2020). This model was executed using Python, specifically applying the LDA 2.0 library, which employs Gibbs sampling as an optimization technique (Levine & Casella, 2006).…”

Enabling Public Security Text-Based Analytics: A Survey to Outline Research Directions

“…The "Support to Law Enforcement agencies' actions" application area is related to providing complete systems architecture, methodologies, and frameworks for agencies dedicated to ensuring compliance with the laws to maintain public security and social welfare. This set is composed of the works by Badii et al [28] that proposed a system architecture to provide data analytics (including a text mining and analytics module) for supporting decision-making in law enforcement agencies; Bisio et al [29] that proposed an approach to allow law enforcement agencies to detect events, using Twitter traffic monitoring, that compromise public security; Basilio et al [30] that presented a methodology to extract knowledge from police reports for extracting information to support activities related to law enforcement; Behmer et al [31] that proposed a framework to support law enforcement agencies in the investigations and analyzes of organized crime; Basilio et al [32] that developed a method for knowledge discovery in emergency response databases based on police reports; and Hou et al [33] that proposed the Bidirectional Encoder Representation from Transformers based on the Chinese relation extraction algorithm for public security, for security information mining.…”

Improving Policing with Natural Language Processing

“…In addition to the previous studies a pair of recent studies conducted with police data from Brazil, (Basilio et al, 2020(Basilio et al, , 2019 utilise unsupervised NLP techniques to cluster crimes with the hope of understanding what policing strategies will be suited to different areas of the city. The authors cluster crimes, then show police officers a representative sample of the clusters and ask them to nominate a suitable policing style (traditional, POP or hot-spot).…”