A mixed-method study of the efficacy of physical activity consultation as an adjunct to standard smoking cessation treatment among male smokers in Malaysia

Abstract

Background This study examined the effectiveness of using Physical Activity Consultation (PAC) as an addition to the standard smoking cessation treatment in Malaysia. We explored participants’ experiences in terms of physical activity and smoking abstinence with the combined PAC and smoking cessation intervention.MethodsWalk-in smokers from a local smoking cessation clinic volunteered for the 8-week intervention program, while undergoing standard smoking cessation treatment. In Week 1, a facilitator conducted a face-to-face intervention to explore participants’ involvement in physical activity and helped to set physical activity strategies and goals for participants to increase physical activity levels. Participants were provided with follow-up phone calls at Weeks 3 and 6. Participants answered questionnaires that measured smoking withdrawal (Shiffman–Jarvik Withdrawal Scale), cessation self-efficacy (Cessation Self-efficacy Questionnaire), physical activity involvement (International Physical Activity Questionnaire), and mood (Brunel Mood Scale) upon recruitment, at post-intervention and at follow-up 3 months after the intervention ended. Participants also responded to interviews about their experiences with the PAC and smoking cessation treatment at post-intervention and at 3-month follow-up.ResultsSeven participants completed the program until follow-up. All were successfully abstinent. Only two participants increased physical activity levels, whereas others maintained their physical activity levels or showed slight decreases. Several themes were identified in this study, including participants’ experiences with withdrawal symptoms, smoking cessation self-efficacy, triggers to smoking cessation, thoughts on standard smoking cessation treatment in Malaysia, physical activity involvement, mood, and thoughts and beliefs on combining smoking cessation and physical activity.ConclusionsThis study suggests PAC was helpful in maintaining or increasing the overall physical activity levels of participants and could assist with smoking abstinence. Findings showed that all participants who stayed in the program were successfully abstinent. In general, the findings in this study provided promising results for further research on PAC as an adjunct to smoking cessation treatments in Malaysia. Trial registration This intervention is registered with the Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry (Trial registration number: ACTRN12616000269437).Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s40064-016-3675-2) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Prevalence of smoking and its association with health-related behaviours among Iranian university students: a large-scale study

“…In line with this finding, a previous Iranian study reported that cigarette cessation was easier in physically active smokers than inactive individuals (27). This finding was also reported in a study from Malaysia (33). We found no study indicating a positive or non-significant association between physical activity and smoking.…”

Participant perceptions of an individualised physical activity anti-smoking intervention

“…The dropout rate was 64 per cent from the beginning of the programme to final follow-up. No clear factor for dropout was identified beyond the suggestion that drop-outs may have been more likely to be employed, supporting Lee et al (2016), and less sedentary, but less healthy at intake. Studies that have examined dropout from smoking cessation programs in non-clinical samples have found widely varying attrition rates.…”

Correlates of Attempts to Quit Smoking: A Hierarchical Multiple Linear Regression Analysis

“…11 Several studies have found that smokers' self-efficacy attempting to quit smoking affected smoking cessation and interventions; it aided in long-term smoking reductions. [12][13][14] If the attitude and subjective norms are favourable, smokers would be motivated to quit smoking with greater perceived behavioral control. However, it needs a firm intention and motivation.…”