A mirror-image analysis of psychiatric hospitalisations among people with severe mental illness using Independent Supported Housing

Abstract

Background Evidence on the effectiveness of Independent Supported Housing (ISH) for non-homeless people with severe mental illness primarily comes from observational cohort studies, which have high risk of bias due to confounding by time-invariant sample characteristics. The present study proposes an alternative study design known from pharmacology to overcome this bias and strengthen evidence. Methods We conducted a retrospective mirror-image analysis with medical records of 144 ISH service users to assess the effectiveness of ISH in reducing the number and duration of hospitalisations. Outcomes occurring in equal periods before and during ISH utilisation were compared for every ISH user. Differences between the periods were tested with incidence rate ratios (IRR). Results Included service users were on average 38.2 years old, female (54%) and predominately had an affective (28.5%) or a schizophrenic or psychotic (22.9%) disorder with ISH utilisation days ranging from 36–960. Fewer admissions (IRR = 0.41, 95%-CI 0.27–0.64) and fewer person-days hospitalised (IRR = 0.38, 95%-CI 0.35–0.41) were observed during ISH utilisation compared to prior to their ISH utilisation. While the reduction in psychiatric admissions may be somewhat confounded by time-variant characteristics, the substantial reduction in hospitalised bed-bays represents at least partially an intervention effect. Conclusions The mirror-image study design allowed for a cost-effective investigation of ISH effectiveness in reducing hospitalisation without confounding by time-invariant sample characteristics. We provide recommendations for the design’s application and suggest further research with larger samples.

Independent Supported Housing for non-homeless individuals with severe mental illness: Comparison of two effectiveness studies using a randomised controlled and an observational study design

“…In addition to the OS design, other quantitative study designs should be explored to complement existing evidence. For example, the self-controlled mirror-image design known from pharmacology has been shown to overcome the risk of confounding owing to time-invariant sample characteristics because every subject acts as its own control ( 60 , 61 ). This design allows for causal inference when time-variant confounding (i.e., regression toward the mean) is adequately addressed ( 60 ).…”

Coercion in Psychiatry - The Human Rights Challenge

“…According to the existing research literature, these instruments have been shown to reduce coercive admissions (de Jong et al, 2016). Residential support services have also been shown to have a preventive effect on admission to psychiatric hospitals (Adamus et al, 2022a, Adamus et al, 2022b. A consistent expansion of outpatient support services, even outside of crisis situations, could make a significant contribution to reducing inpatient stays.…”

Long-acting injectable antipsychotics for the treatment of bipolar disorder: evidence from mirror-image studies

“…In addition, they generally include representative samples, testing objective outcome variables, such as the number of hospital admissions or emergency department visits. 19 , 21 , 22 However, evidence from mirror-image studies investigating LAIs in BD is scattered and has not been systematically evaluated so far. This would be helpful to clarify the possible role of LAIs for the maintenance treatment of BD from the relevant body of evidence accumulated in the last few years.…”