“…In the simulated materials by some authors [42,52,43,9], the water bridges between particles are based on the Young-Laplace solution and the sample moisture content is constant, while the toroidal shape water bridge model is also adopted by some other researchers [7] and they obtained similar material behaviours. Furthermore, suction controlled simulations are carried out [47,48,58], in which matric suction is constantly maintained through the sample. Recently, Gladkyy and Schwarze [11] compared the DEM simulation results by using different water bridge model, and it is observed that the macroscopic results are closed to each other.…”