An increasing number of redox-active substances with
improved electrochemical
stability is currently being reported in the literature for potential
applications in redox flow batteries (RFBs). Consequently, the demand
for methods capable of estimating the long-term stability of redox
couples is increasing as well. It seems to be of particular importance
to understand the limitations of existing stability assessment techniques.
In this work, two recently established and highly promising stability
assessment techniques are directly compared for the first time to
measure the capacity fade rate of a N,N′-dimethyl-4,4′-bipyridinium dichloride (methyl viologen
or MV) molecule as a benchmark anolyte substance. These two methods
are the unbalanced, compositionally symmetric flow cell cycling (symmetric
cycling or UCSFCC) and the steady-state amperometric state of health
(ASOH) measurement. The results of the symmetric cycling indicate
a 3-fold higher stability for MV compared to a previous literature
report as well as a high standard deviation for the measured capacity
fade rate. More comprehensive investigations of the technique revealed
that the influence of the MV purity, electrolyte leakage, and membrane
cross-over could not cause the difference between the measured and
earlier reported capacity fades and, thus, indicated insufficiency
of the technique’s accuracy for the measurement of highly stable
redox species. ASOH as the second technique exhibited similar capacity
fade rates like the symmetric cycling as well as comparably high standard
deviations. Furthermore, it is prone to temperature fluctuations and
variations of the electrode radius. Thus, we demonstrate an approach
for a temperature correction in this method, which enables significantly
higher accuracy and reliability. Despite this, the variation of the
electrode radius remains the main concern for this technique. Based
on the obtained results for the MV anolyte, the state and prospects
of both techniques for the stability assessment in RFB research are
discussed in detail.