A meta‐analysis of the educational effectiveness of three‐dimensional visualization technologies in teaching anatomy

Abstract

Many medical graduates are deficient in anatomy knowledge and perhaps below the standards for safe medical practice. Three-dimensional visualization technology (3DVT) has been advanced as a promising tool to enhance anatomy knowledge. The purpose of this review is to conduct a meta-analysis of the effectiveness of 3DVT in teaching and learning anatomy compared to all teaching methods. The primary outcomes were scores of anatomy knowledge tests expressed as factual or spatial knowledge percentage means. Secondary outcomes were perception scores of the learners. Thirty-six studies met the inclusion criteria including 28 (78%) randomized studies. Based on 2,226 participants including 2,128 from studies with comparison groups, 3DVTs (1) resulted in higher (d = 0.30, 95%CI: 0.02-0.62) factual knowledge, (2) yielded significant better results (d = 0.50, 95%CI: 0.20-0.80) in spatial knowledge acquisition, and (3) produced significant increase in user satisfaction (d = 0.28, 95%CI = 0.12-0.44) and in learners' perception of the effectiveness of the learning tool (d = 0.28, 95%CI = 0.14-0.43). The total mean scores (out of five) and ±SDs for QUESTS's Quality and Strength dimensions were 4.38 (±SD 1.3) and 3.3 (±SD 1.7), respectively. The results have high internal validity, for the improved outcomes of 3DVTs compared to other methods of anatomy teaching. Given that anatomy teaching and learning in the modern medical school appears to be approaching a crisis, 3DVT can be a potential solution to the problem of inadequate anatomy pedagogy.

Rethinking Anatomy: How to Overcome Challenges of Medical Education’s Evolution

“…55 Similarly, Yammine and Violato showed that the pedagogical use of 3DTV yields better results when compared to their 2D counterparts, regarding learning factual Anatomy, with substantial educational benefits on spatial Anatomy knowledge. 56 Also, this learning perspective might contribute to improving the connection and feedback between teacher and students, for instance through social media network 30,31 and, subsequently, cause an impact in learner's performance. 57 The introduction of computer integrated systems in Anatomy Education lends itself to a better analysis of the teaching-learning-assessment dimensions, at the same time, delivering new environments to that processes.…”

Computer Assisted Learning: Assessment of the Veterinary Virtual Anatomy Education Software IVALA™

“…Students describe CAL anatomy instruction as enjoyable [21,22,23] and accept computer-based interactive technology as an effective approach in conveying anatomical information [24,25]. Advantages of supplementing traditional methods with CAL include novel anatomic perspective, increased portability and longevity, and increased standardization [26,27]. …”

Teaching anatomy in a modern medical course: an integrated approach at Vialba Medical School in Milan

“…Then, in the clinical years of the medical curriculum this concept will need to be retained and strengthened, since the anatomical variability plays an essential role in clinical activity (Sañudo 2003;Yammine and Violato 2015), markedly influencing medical choices and, above all, surgical practice (Marcos 2000).…”