“A manager in the minds of doctors:” a comparison of new modes of control in European hospitals

Abstract

BackgroundHospital governance increasingly combines management and professional self-governance. This article maps the new emergent modes of control in a comparative perspective and aims to better understand the relationship between medicine and management as hybrid and context-dependent. Theoretically, we critically review approaches into the managerialism-professionalism relationship; methodologically, we expand cross-country comparison towards the meso-level of organisations; and empirically, the focus is on processes and actors in a range of European hospitals.MethodsThe research is explorative and was carried out as part of the FP7 COST action IS0903 Medicine and Management, Working Group 2. Comprising seven European countries, the focus is on doctors and public hospitals. We use a comparative case study design that primarily draws on expert information and document analysis as well as other secondary sources.ResultsThe findings reveal that managerial control is not simply an external force but increasingly integrated in medical professionalism. These processes of change are relevant in all countries but shaped by organisational settings, and therefore create different patterns of control: (1) ‘integrated’ control with high levels of coordination and coherent patterns for cost and quality controls; (2) ‘partly integrated’ control with diversity of coordination on hospital and department level and between cost and quality controls; and (3) ‘fragmented’ control with limited coordination and gaps between quality control more strongly dominated by medicine, and cost control by management.ConclusionsOur comparison highlights how organisations matter and brings the crucial relevance of ‘coordination’ of medicine and management across the levels (hospital/department) and the substance (cost/quality-safety) of control into perspective. Consequently, coordination may serve as a taxonomy of emergent modes of control, thus bringing new directions for cost-efficient and quality-effective hospital governance into perspective.

New public management, physicians and populism: Turkey's experience with health reforms

“…It pays attention to the variations of the interrelationships among organisations, professions, practices and experiences on the meso‐level of organisations (Kuhlmann et al . , Wrede et al . ).…”

“…, Kuhlmann et al . , McDonald ). The professionals respond differently to changing policy and governance arrangements and governments may utilise the professional experts strategically as a governance tool (Burau ).…”

Reconfiguring health workforce: a case-based comparative study explaining the increasingly diverse professional roles in Europe

“…To ensure comparability between sites and between countries, a consistent data analysis approach was developed. During the data collection and analysis, researchers discussed issues emerging from data collection and intermediate results at monthly online meetings and during two face-to-face workshops [31, 32]. At the first workshop, researchers were updated on the approaches to take in interviewing and observation.…”

Exploring staff experience of economic efficiency requirements in health care: A mixed method study

“…Concurrently, empirical studies have identified medically informed managers who function as a “hybrid,” successfully bringing professionalism and managerialism together . However, this has mainly been studied with hybrid managers in focus, exploring their abilities to articulate economic efficiency requirements in relation to clinical work and to adapt communication to professional culture .…”