A Longitudinal Study of the Impact of Interviews on Medical School Admissions in Taiwan

Abstract

Medical schools in Taiwan have recently adopted the U.S. medical school admissions model by incorporating interviews into the selection process. The objective of this study was to investigate factors that contribute to successful medical school applications through the national entrance examination and interview admission routes. The sample consisted of survey data from five entry cohorts of medical students admitted to the National Yang-Ming University Faculty of Medicine from 2003 to 2007. Of the 513 students, 62% were admitted through the traditional national entrance examination route and 38% were admitted early after achieving a threshold score on the composite national exam followed by a structured interview. Students admitted through the interview route were more likely to be female, with an odds ratio (OR) of 2.17 (1.20-3.93). Maternal education level was an independent predictor of both early admission through a successful interview and higher medical school grade point average (GPA). Students admitted through the interview route had a 3.20 point higher first-year medical school GPA (p < .001) as determined by regression analyses. Those students who were admitted via interview did not have significantly different personality traits than those admitted through the traditional route. This study calls into question the ability of an admissions interview to select for noncognitive character traits.

How effective are selection methods in medical education? A systematic review

“…Despite some evidence to the contrary, the balance of evidence suggests that generally, the traditional interview is not a robust method of selecting medical students, and lacks predictive validity . Edwards et al .…”

Being Interviewed for Admission to a BSN Program: A Qualitative Inquiry

“…Including an interview as part of the admission process allows the faculty to examine students' fit within the program and the school. Multiple articles have been published regarding the process of admission interviews in various health professional programs [4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16]. Admission processes are created with the intention of admitting candidates with the greatest possibility of success.…”

Intelligent higher institution student selection system

“…The crisp input for income corresponds to the membership function low and average to the degree of 0. 5 Defuzzification. The last step in the Sugeno-Style procedure is to find the weighted average (WA) of the aggregation process.…”

“…Among the criteria considered are cognitive assessment and also the non-cognitive assessment [2] such as high school results [1], transferred credits hours [3], specific entrance examination [4] and interview [5]. Other criteria such as the applicant's artistic, athletic and academic interest, the total fees that the applicants have to pay and the applicants' race were also considered when determining the qualification of the applicant [6].…”