A learning development-faculty collaborative exploration of postgraduate research student mental health in a UK university

Abstract

Mental ill-health is an escalating problem in higher education. Not only does this impact students’ ability to learn, it can lead to poor completion, with learners opting to withdraw from studies, even if attainment has been satisfactory. The aim of this study was to gain insight about perceptions of poor mental health from postgraduate research students in a diverse UK university and canvas opinion regarding how the University could improve this. A short, pragmatic survey with basic quantitative and qualitative responses was distributed. This was analysed by a team comprising the learning developer responsible for postgraduate researcher learning development, academics and a doctoral student. The study found that poor mental health was evident, with over three quarters of respondents reporting some experience of mental ill-health. We identified five areas in need of attention: University Systems, Supervisor Training, Well-being Monitoring, Building Networks, and Finance. Sources of University-based stress were finance, administrative support, and an environment where a perception that poor mental health was an expectation rather than a problem was experienced. Students preferred to access support outside the academic environment. This is the first study of its kind at a diverse, plate-glass UK university, to consider research student mental ill-health, with a staff-student team working with data, and the learning developer spear-heading changes across postgraduate research. These findings have already influenced university strategy, staff training, and induction practices. The synthesis of the five areas could be used to visualise where further work is needed to improve mental health in these learners.

The Developmental Trajectory of a Decade of Research on Mental Health and Well-Being amongst Graduate Students: A Bibliometric Analysis

“…Even though some studies have reported on the literature in different subject fields, there have been no bibliometric studies explicitly conducted on graduate students' mental health and well-being. Quantitative surveys have been undertaken on Economics graduate students' mental health [16], the mental health crisis in graduate education [14], the link between mental health and doctoral students [15], experiences of belonging in relation to mental health and well-being [36], and the perceptions on and assessment of mental health [37,38]. Another study used critical self-reflections on postgraduate researchers' mental health and well-being [39].…”

Navigating Uncertainty

“…This is particularly relevant in the current project, where participants were not referred to participate within a health context, but rather, self-nominated to join the program in order to grapple with a challenge they were facing. Although research into the mental health of PhD researchers suggests that several of them may have also been diagnosed with mental ill health (Delderfield et al, 2020;Naumann et al, 2022), this was not the participant's focus and therefore it was important not to pathologise their attempts at self-care.…”

Inclusive learning development practices: the consequences of flexibility and choice in the hybrid era

“…Additionally, a major limitation of the online medium is the reduced non-verbal communication resulting in less efficient communication, potential frustration, and disruption to wellbeing monitoring during one-to-one LD tutorials (Delderfield et al, 2020).…”