A Hybrid Approach of VIKOR and Bi-Objective Decision Model for Emergency Shelter Location–Allocation to Respond to Earthquakes

Abstract

Earthquakes have catastrophic effects on the affected population, especially in undeveloped countries or regions. Minimizing the impact and consequences of earthquakes involves many decisions and disaster relief operations that should be optimized. A critical disaster management problem is to construct shelters with reasonable capacity in the right locations, allocate evacuees, and provide relief materials to them within a reasonable period. This study proposes a bi-objective hierarchical model with two stages, namely, the temporary shelter stage and the short-term shelter stage. The proposed objectives at different stages are to minimize the evacuation time, maximize the suitability based on qualitative factors, and minimize the number of sites while considering the demand, capacity, utilization, and budget constraints. The performance evaluation of the emergency shelter was carried out by fuzzy-VIKOR, and the most ideal location of the shelter was determined through multiple standards. Emergency management organizations can benefit from the collective expertise of multiple decision-makers because the proposed method uses their knowledge to automate the location and allocation process of shelters. In the case of Chengdu, Sichuan Province, China, the results of using this hybrid approach provide the government with a range of options. This method can realize the trade-off between efficiency and cost in the emergency shelter location and material distribution, and realize reliable solutions in disaster emergencies.

Generalized Weighted Mahalanobis Distance Improved VIKOR Model for Rockburst Classification Evaluation

“…The VIKOR (VIseKriterijumska Optimizacija I Kompromisno Resenje) method, originally introduced by Opricovic in 1998, is a multi-attribute decision-making approach aimed at discovering ideal alternatives for complex systems [51]. It begins by defining positive and negative ideal alternatives, representing the best and worst values for each evaluation criterion among all available alternatives [52].…”

A bi-objective humanitarian logistics model considering equity in the affected zones: application to a recent earthquake in Mexico

“…Recently, the study of Geng et al [18] addresses a two-stage optimization approach of shelter allocation. The first stage is a bi-objective problem that determines the type-and-location of emergency shelters in multiple planning periods, optimizing the suitability of the emergency shelters and the distance travelled by evacuees and delivered materials.…”

Research on site selection of emergency material reserve based on set pair analysis and TOPSIS integration method: A case study of Hebei Province, China

“…Due to the uncertainty in the index system for the site selection of emergency facilities, Chu et al [13] introduced the fuzzy theory and proposed a fuzzy TOPSIS model, which used the linguistic value expressed by fuzzy numbers to evaluate the ratings of various alternative locations under different subjective attributes and determined the importance weights of all attributes. In addition, Geng et al [14] has built a twolayer model of temporary refuge stage and short-term refuge stage, and proposes a fuzzy VIKOR evaluation method considering uncertainty, which provides a new idea for location selection. In addition to the above single method to solve the site problem, many scholars also put forward the idea of combining multiple methods.…”