A Hybrid Analytical and Data-Driven Approach for Improved Prediction of Recovery Performance in Tight Oil Reservoirs

Abstract

Summary The heterogeneity of tight reservoirs, along with their complex geologic characteristics and the diverse completion practices used, presents challenges in developing accurate models to forecast the productivity for multifractured horizontal wells (MFHWs) completed in these reservoirs. This paper introduces a new early-time diagnostic tool that leverages early-time two-phase flowback data to forecast long-term productivity and evaluate completion efficiency. To achieve this, two novel models were developed. The first model, the water/oil-ratio model (WORM), uses a hybrid analytical and data-driven approach to describe the observed log-linear relationship between water/oil ratio (WOR) and load recovery (amount of fracturing water produced back after hydraulic fracturing operations) as an analogy to the log-linear relationship between the water/oil relative permeability ratio and water saturation. Next, a neural network is used to couple WORM parameters with key petrophysical properties to analyze the impact of fracture and formation properties on WOR performance, predict WOR as a function of load recovery, forecast ultimate load recovery, and estimate effective fracture volume and initial water saturation in fracture. The second model, the cumulative oil production model (COPM), is a data-driven model that predicts oil production as a function of load recovery during the matrix-dominated flow regime. The application of WORM and COPM on Niobrara and Codell formation wells showed that Codell wells generally exhibit better load recovery and larger effective fracture volume compared with Niobrara wells, but both formations exhibit similar oil recovery performance, indicating independent flow regimes within the effective fractures. The effective fracture volume estimated by WORM was validated against the estimated volume from recorded microseismic events. The results also showed that using the same completion practice to achieve a similar effective fracture volume in child wells does not necessarily lead to similar oil productivity. This paper introduces a holistic workflow that links early two-phase flowback data with well productivity and completion efficiency and is anticipated to aid petroleum engineers in optimizing hydraulic fracturing operations.