A Holistic Model for the Selection of Environmental Assessment Indicators to Assess the Impact of Industrialization on Indigenous Health

Abstract

Objectives: Mainstream environmental assessment (EA) methodologies often inadequately address health, social and cultural impacts of concern for Canadian indigenous communities affected by industrialization. Our objective is to present a holistic, culturally-appropriate framework for the selection of indigenous health indicators for baseline health assessment, impact prediction, or monitoring of impacts over time. Methods: We used a critical population health approach to explore the determinants of health and health inequities in indigenous communities and conceptualize the pathways by which industrialization affects these determinants. We integrated and extended key elements from three indigenous health frameworks into a new holistic model for the selection of indigenous EA indicators. Results: The holistic model conceptualizes individual and community determinants of health within external social, economic and political contexts and thus provides a comprehensive framework for selecting indicators of indigenous health. Indigenous health is the product of interactions among multiple determinants of health and contexts. Potential applications are discussed using case study examples involving indigenous communities affected by industrialization. Conclusion: Industrialization can worsen indigenous health inequities by perpetuating the health, social and cultural impacts of historic environmental dispossession. To mitigate impacts, EA should explicitly recognize linkages between environmental dispossession and the determinants of health and health inequities and meaningfully involve indigenous communities in the process.

Canada First Nations Strengths in Community-Based Primary Healthcare

“…Thus, knowledge of and liberty to practice culture and spirituality, including the harvesting and use of traditional medicines and healing approaches to support wellbeing and non-medical needs of patients are crucial [ 28 ]. Reconnection to lands has been identified as a determinant of health [ 80 ], with capacity to heal the effects of dispossession [ 81 , 82 ]. Higher income and education are understood as strongly correlated with higher self-reported health among Indigenous populations [ 83 ].…”

Concerted Model of Healthcare for Awá Indigenous of Nariño, Colombia

“…As other authors have pointed out, the result is the strengthening of the capacity of communities based on their own view and regardless of models outside of their worldview, while still retaining elements and resources from existing services. This constitutes a key element for reducing health inequities [23][24][25].…”

Academic Institutions and One Health

“… 35 Holistic methods of HIA that are based on a transdisciplinary framework are required to adequately address health, social, and cultural impacts on indigenous communities that are affected by industrialization. 36 …”